01
Closest small-town classic
Cygnet Pizza & Subs
Cygnet, South Of Bloomdale • Carryout Pizzeria And Sub Shop • Local Favorite
A small-town staple known for generously topped pies, subs, and those addictive breadstick nuggets.
Roughly a 10–15 minute drive from Bloomdale, this no-frills shop in Cygnet is the kind of place locals grow up on. The pizza leans hearty Midwestern, with plenty of cheese and toppings and crust that stands up well to takeout. Add an order of their breadstick nuggets and a sub and you have an easy, crowd-pleasing meal on the way home.
02
Best for big groups and variety
Heavenly Pizza
East Side Of Findlay • Family-Friendly Delivery And Carryout Spot • Best For Families
A long-running Findlay favorite with a big menu, reliable delivery, and pizza that pleases a wide range of tastes.
About 20 minutes from Bloomdale, Heavenly Pizza is a go-to when you are feeding a group and want options. The crust is classic and slightly chewy, with plenty of traditional and specialty topping combinations, plus subs, salads, and sides to round things out. It is especially handy if you are staying on the east side of Findlay and want delivery back to your hotel or rental.
03
Old-school Fostoria standby
Auriola’s Pizza
South Fostoria • Casual Family Pizzeria • Neighborhood Classic
A Fostoria institution turning out shareable pies with a straightforward, no-gimmicks approach.
Head about 10 miles west to Fostoria and you will find Auriola’s, a simple, friendly shop where the focus is squarely on the pizza. Expect familiar combinations, plenty of cheese, and crust that hits the sweet spot between soft and crisp. It is an easy choice when you want a relaxed, small-town pizza night without driving all the way to a bigger city.
04
Best for game-night vibes
Jack & Beans Pizza
Central Fostoria • Pizza Pub And Sports Hangout • Best For Watching The Game
A laid-back spot where you can grab a hot pie, a drink, and catch a game with locals.
This Fostoria hangout is about 15 minutes from Bloomdale and works well when you want more than just takeout. The pizza is classic bar-style with plenty of toppings, and the casual atmosphere makes it easy to linger over a pitcher and a couple of pies. It is the kind of place where you can show up in game-day gear and feel right at home.
05
Worth-the-drive college-town option
Padrone’s Pizza
Bowling Green, Near Downtown • College-Town Pizza Joint • Late-Night Pick
A Bowling Green staple with big, topping-heavy pies that hit the spot after a long day or late evening.
If you are willing to drive around 25 minutes north, Padrone’s in Bowling Green gives you a livelier college-town take on pizza. Slices are sturdy, cheesy, and built for sharing, and the menu runs from straightforward pepperoni to loaded specialty pies. It is a smart stop if you are combining a trip to BG with a pizza run or looking for a later-night option than you will usually find in the smaller towns around Bloomdale.