01
Best overall pick
DeFelice Bros. Pizza
Wintersville, Along The Us-22 Corridor • Family-Friendly Ohio Valley-Style Pizzeria • Best All-Around Choice
A go-to spot for hearty, cheese-heavy pies that please just about everyone.
From Bloomingdale, DeFelice in Wintersville is an easy drive when you want a classic Ohio Valley-style pizza night. The crust is sturdy but not heavy, with plenty of cheese and toppings piled edge to edge. It’s the kind of place locals rely on for everything from casual weeknight dinners to team parties.
02
Classic Ohio Valley slice
DiCarlo's Original Pizza
Wintersville, Near The Main Strip • Counter-Service Square-Cut Shop • Must-Try Local Classic
Crisp, airy squares finished with cheese after the bake for that signature Ohio Valley bite.
DiCarlo’s is the name most people mention when they talk about true Ohio Valley pizza. Pies come out of the oven with sauce and crust first, then get topped with a layer of cool shredded cheese that melts just enough as you eat. It’s a simple, old-school setup with quick service and a menu built around doing one thing really well.
03
Neighborhood favorite
Giannamore's Pizza
Steubenville, Residential West Side • No-Frills Takeout Pizzeria • Best For Carryout Comfort Food
Thick, cheesy trays of pizza that feel built for movie nights and game days.
Giannamore’s leans into comforting, saucy trays of pizza that travel well back to Bloomingdale. The crust has a little more heft, making it easy to feed a crowd without breaking the bank. Call ahead on busy nights, because locals have been ordering from here for years.
04
Sit-down Italian night
Naples Spaghetti House
Downtown Steubenville • Old-School Italian Restaurant With Pizza • Best For A Relaxed Dine-In Meal
A historic Italian dining room where you can pair classic pies with big plates of pasta.
If you want more of a night out than a quick pickup order, Naples Spaghetti House delivers the full red-sauce experience. The pizza leans traditional, with a chewy crust and balanced sauce, and you can round it out with salads, pasta, and a glass of wine. It’s a comfortable choice for family gatherings or low-key date nights after a day exploring the valley.
05
Delivery standout
Vocelli Pizza
Steubenville Hilltop Area • Chain Pizzeria With Customizable Pies • Best For Late-Night Delivery
Reliable, customizable pizzas with plenty of toppings and crust options, delivered out toward the smaller towns.
When convenience matters most, Vocelli is the spot many Bloomingdale residents have on speed dial. The menu runs from classic pepperoni to specialty pies, wings, and breadsticks, so it’s easy to keep a mixed group happy. It’s especially handy on weeknights when you want dinner to come to you.