01
Best overall pick
LaRosa's Pizzeria – Harrison
Harrison • Family-Friendly Cincinnati-Style Pizzeria • West Side Classic
A go-to spot for LaRosa’s signature thin-crust pies and crowd-pleasing family dinners.
If you’re in Blue Jay and want something everyone at the table will agree on, the Harrison LaRosa’s is the easy answer. The crust is thin but sturdy, the sauce has that familiar sweet Cincinnati edge, and there are enough topping combos to satisfy both purists and picky eaters. It’s the kind of place where staff recognize regulars and takeout is just as dependable as dining in.
02
Best takeout slice
Trotta's Pizza – Bridgetown
Bridgetown • Old-School Carryout Pizzeria • Carryout Favorite
Thick, cheesy squares and quick service make Trotta’s a staple for West Side pizza nights.
Trotta’s is a name you hear often when West Siders talk about their go-to Friday night pizza. The pies lean hearty, with a chewy crust, plenty of cheese, and classic toppings that hold up well to the drive back toward Blue Jay. It’s built for carryout: call ahead, swing through, and you’re back home with a still-hot box in under an hour door to door.
03
Neighborhood favorite
Noce's Pizza
West Side Cincinnati • Casual Neighborhood Pie Shop • Best For Regulars
A low-key west-side joint turning out dependable, generously topped pies and garlic bread.
Noce’s feels like the kind of pizza shop that’s been part of the neighborhood forever, with straightforward pies and zero pretense. The crust strikes a balance between crisp and doughy, and they’re not shy with cheese or toppings. It’s an easy choice when you’re already on the West Side and want something satisfying without making a whole night of it.
04
Big-portion pick
Adriatico's New York Style Pizza
Clifton Near Uc • Hearty College-Town Pizzeria • Best For Big Groups
Famous for massive, bready pies loaded with cheese and toppings, ideal for sharing.
Adriatico’s is a bit of a drive from Blue Jay, but many locals make the trip when they want a truly oversized, sauce-heavy pie. The thick, edge-to-edge cheese and robust toppings make each slice a meal on its own, which is why it’s a staple for UC students and big families alike. Call ahead for a large or Sicilian-style pan pizza and plan on leftovers for the next day.
05
Creative pies pick
Dewey's Pizza – Oakley
Oakley • Craft Pizza And Beer Spot • Best For Creative Toppings
Inventive specialty pies, a good beer list, and a polished but relaxed dining room.
When you’re in the mood to make pizza the centerpiece of a night out, Dewey’s in Oakley is worth the extra miles from Blue Jay. The menu leans into creative combinations—think specialty white pies, seasonal toppings, and well-balanced flavor pairings—alongside the build-your-own standbys. Open kitchen views and a solid tap list make it a good choice for date nights or meeting friends from other parts of town.