01
Classic Warren institution
Sunrise Inn of Warren
Downtown Warren • Old-School Tavern Pizzeria • Local Classic
A downtown landmark known for hearty pies, Brier Hill-style pizza, and a lively, no-frills dining room.
If you ask around Bolindale or Warren for a go-to pizza, Sunrise Inn is the name that comes up most. The crust is sturdy and crispy enough to handle generous toppings, and the Brier Hill pizza with peppers and Romano is a true Mahoning Valley staple. It’s the kind of place where families, softball teams, and old friends all crowd into the same booths on a Friday night.
02
Neighborhood takeout favorite
Red Plum Pizza & Pasta
Elm Road / North Warren • Takeout Pizza And Pasta Shop • Best For Takeout
A dependable Elm Road stop for generous pizzas, subs, and baked pasta trays when you’re feeding a crowd.
Red Plum leans into big flavors and big portions, which makes it a smart move for game days or casual get-togethers near Bolindale. The crust runs on the slightly thicker side with a good chew, and they don’t skimp on cheese or toppings. Pair a sheet pizza with an order of wings or pasta and you’re set for the evening.
03
Sit-down Italian pick
Salvatore's Italian Grill
Howland Corners • Sit-Down Italian Grill With Brick-Oven Pies • Best For Family Dinners
A polished but relaxed Italian spot where pizza shares the spotlight with pastas, salads, and classics from the grill.
When you want pizza but also a proper sit-down meal, Salvatore’s in Howland fits the bill. Their pizzas come with a well-browned, slightly blistered crust and toppings that feel a notch more refined than the average delivery joint. It’s a comfortable choice for multi-generational family dinners, with plenty on the menu for the non-pizza people at the table.
04
Youngstown-style standout
Wedgewood Pizza
Howland / Niles-Cortland Road • Youngstown-Style Sheet-Pizza Joint • Game-Day Crowd Favorite
A regional favorite turning out thick, chewy-crust sheet pizzas that are built to share.
Wedgewood brings the Youngstown-style tradition close to Bolindale, with square-cut pies that balance a sturdy crust, tangy sauce, and plenty of cheese. The sheet pizzas travel well, which makes them ideal for parties, tailgates, and school events. Call ahead at peak times—locals know what they like here and the orders stack up fast on weekends.
05
Closest chain comfort
Pizza Hut
E Market Street Corridor • National Chain Carryout And Delivery • Most Convenient Near Bolindale
A familiar option just down East Market, with the classic pan pizzas, wings, and specials you expect from Pizza Hut.
For Bolindale residents, this East Market Street Pizza Hut is often the quickest way to get a hot pizza on the table. The menu sticks to the national playbook—pan, hand-tossed, and stuffed-crust pies with predictable toppings and frequent deals. It’s not trying to be a gourmet destination, but for busy weeknights or last-minute orders, the convenience is hard to beat.