01
Best overall pick
Meyers Tavern
Downtown Botkins • Hometown Tavern With Pizza And Subs • Local Favorite For Classic Pies
A small‑town tavern known for generously topped pizzas and friendly, familiar service.
Meyers Tavern is the kind of place where the staff knows regulars by name and the pizza comes piled with toppings edge to edge. The crust is sturdy enough to hold up under extra cheese and meat, making it a go‑to for game nights and casual dinners. It’s an easy first choice if you want something close to home with that true Botkins feel.
02
Best small‑town slice
Al's Pizza
Downtown Wapakoneta • Classic Small‑Town Pizzeria • Laid‑Back Option For Hand‑Tossed Pies
A cozy Main Street shop turning out straightforward, well‑made hand‑tossed pizzas.
Al's Pizza has the familiar feel of an old‑school Ohio pizzeria, with hand‑tossed crusts and plenty of customization. The sauce leans savory, and the cheese browns nicely, making even simple pepperoni feel satisfying. It’s a solid choice when you’re in Wapakoneta and want an unfussy pie after a day of errands or a local event.
03
Best for families
Amelio's Pizzeria
Sidney • Family‑Friendly Pizzeria And Dine‑In Spot • Great For Groups And Kids
A sit‑down pizzeria in Sidney where big pies, sharable appetizers, and friendly service make it easy to bring the whole crew.
Amelio's Pizzeria caters to families and larger groups, with shareable pizzas and plenty of seating. Expect a menu that goes beyond basic cheese and pepperoni, with combination pies that cover the table and keep everyone happy. It’s a good pick when you want to make an evening of it rather than just grab a box and go.
04
Best for variety
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill
St. Marys • Lively Pizza And Grill Restaurant • Great For Mixed Tastes And Bigger Appetites
A regional favorite where crispy‑edged pizzas share the menu with hearty pub food and a full bar.
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill is ideal when not everyone in the group wants the same thing, but pizza still needs to be the star. The crust runs on the thinner, crispier side, with plenty of specialty combinations and a good spread of toppings. With a busy dining room and a full grill menu, it works well for everything from team celebrations to casual weekend dinners.
05
Best late‑night option
Domino's Pizza
Sidney • Carryout And Delivery Chain Pizzeria • Reliable Pick For Quick, Customizable Pizza
A dependable choice for fast delivery pies with lots of crust, sauce, and topping options.
When convenience matters as much as the pizza, Domino's in Sidney covers the basics with consistent, made‑to‑order pies. The online ordering and build‑your‑own options make it easy to get exactly what you want, from thin crusts to hearty pan styles. It’s especially useful for last‑minute gatherings, late‑night cravings, or when you’re staying in around Botkins and want a box delivered to the door.