01
Best overall pick
Cardo's Pizza & Tavern
Bainbridge Village Center • Small-Town Tavern Pizzeria • Local Hangout With Classic Pies
A short drive west of Bourneville, Cardo's serves generous, old-school pies in a low-key tavern that feels very much like Bainbridge's living room.
Cardo's is the spot locals lean on for game nights, casual family dinners, and big, shareable pizzas with plenty of toppings. Expect a slightly thicker crust, lots of cheese, and a menu that stretches into wings and bar-style appetizers. It’s an easy choice when you want a full sit-down pizza night without driving all the way to Chillicothe.
02
Worth the drive to town
Cristy's Pizza
Downtown Chillicothe • Carryout And Delivery Pizza Shop • Best For Reliable Carryout
Cristy's in downtown Chillicothe is a go-to for consistent, crowd-pleasing pizzas that travel well back to Bourneville.
Known for its chewy crust, balanced sauce, and generous toppings, Cristy's is a favorite for family orders and team dinners. The downtown location makes it easy to swing by after errands or while passing through town. If you’re feeding a group back in Bourneville, their specialty pies and big salads make planning simple.
03
Crispy thin-crust specialist
Donatos Pizza
North Bridge Street, Chillicothe Shopping Strip • Thin-Crust Regional Chain • Best For Crispy Thin Crust
Donatos on North Bridge Street turns out signature thin-crust pizzas loaded edge-to-edge with toppings, ideal for those who like a crunchier bite.
If you prefer your pizza on the lighter, crispier side, Donatos is the natural pick within an easy drive of Bourneville. Their square-cut pies are built for sharing, and the menu stretches from classic pepperoni to lighter veggie options and salads. It’s a convenient stop when you’re already on the main retail strip and want pizza that holds up well for the ride home.
04
Hearty crowd-pleaser
Giovanni's Pizza
Just Off U.S. 50 In Bainbridge • Casual Dine-In And Carryout Pizzeria • Best For Hearty Slices
Giovanni's serves up saucy, cheese-heavy pizzas that feel tailor-made for refueling after a day on the road or at the lake.
Portions here lean generous, with a slightly thicker crust and plenty of melted cheese that make each slice feel substantial. The atmosphere is relaxed and unfussy, the kind of place where nobody rushes you and kids are welcome. It’s a strong choice when you want classic, filling pizza without driving into the busier parts of Chillicothe.
05
Closest slice to Bourneville
Valero Bourneville
Along State Route 50 In Bourneville • Convenience-Store Counter Pizza • Quickest Grab-And-Go Option
Right in Bourneville, the Valero station doubles as a handy spot for a hot, made-to-order pizza when you don’t feel like leaving town.
This isn’t a sit-down pizzeria, but for many locals it’s the most practical way to get a fresh pie without a long drive. The pizzas are straightforward and customizable enough for a weeknight dinner or a spur-of-the-moment pickup. If you’re heading home along Route 50 and want something hot and easy, it’s tough to beat the convenience.