01
Best overall pick
Gionino's Pizzeria
Uhrichsville • Neighborhood Carryout Pizzeria • Local Favorite
Big, garlicky pies and generous toppings make Gionino's a go-to stop for Bowerston folks heading through Uhrichsville.
Gionino's leans into hearty, classic Ohio-style pizza with a crust that holds up well under plenty of cheese and toppings. It is an easy detour if you are already in Uhrichsville for errands or heading toward New Philadelphia. Call ahead on weekend evenings; the rush can back up the ovens, but the pies travel well back to Bowerston.
02
Best for variety
East of Chicago Pizza
Uhrichsville • Casual Chain Pizzeria • Best For Big Groups
East of Chicago in Uhrichsville is where you go for thick crust, buffet-style options, and enough variety to keep a crowd happy.
Known for its pan and Chicago-style crusts, East of Chicago is ideal when everyone wants something a little different. Specialty pies, wings, and a solid salad option make it easy to feed a family or a small team after a game. It is a straightforward, no-frills spot, but the portions and value make it worth the short drive from Bowerston.
03
Most convenient dine-in
Pizza Hut
Cadiz • Family-Friendly Chain Restaurant • Best For Families
The Cadiz Pizza Hut offers familiar pies, a salad bar when available, and a sit-down option close to Bowerston.
If you want a predictable pizza night without driving far, the Cadiz Pizza Hut is usually the simplest answer. Classic pan and thin-crust pizzas, plus pasta and wings, keep the menu easy and kid-friendly. Service is geared toward carryout, but the dining room can be a relaxed stop after shopping or a ball game in town.
04
Best late-night option
Domino's Pizza
New Philadelphia • Delivery-Focused Chain • Late-Night Pick
Domino's in New Philadelphia is a reliable choice when you are out late and want a hot pie with customizable crust and toppings.
While it is a bit farther from Bowerston, Domino's earns its place on the list for consistency and later hours compared with smaller local shops. The online ordering and pizza tracker make it easy to time your pickup on the way back from town. It is not a destination spot, but for a fast, no-surprises pizza, it gets the job done.
05
Best sit-down experience
Dennison Yard
Dennison • Railroad-Themed Bar And Grill • Best For A Relaxed Evening
Dennison Yard pairs crisp, tavern-style pizzas with a laid-back dining room set in a restored rail-side building.
This is the place to linger over pizza rather than just grabbing a box to go. Pies come out with a thinner, crispier crust and a good balance of cheese and sauce, alongside sandwiches and a solid beer list. It is especially nice for meeting friends or family from different corners of the county, since Dennison sits roughly between Bowerston and the busier towns to the west.