01
Best overall pick
Pizza Oven – Navarre
Navarre, Just North Of Brewster • Classic Stark County Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Big Flavor And Value
Thick, cheesy pies and pepperoni rolls that taste like Stark County in a box.
If you ask around Brewster or Navarre where to order pizza, Pizza Oven comes up fast. The Navarre shop turns out hefty, slightly crisped crusts, a generous blanket of cheese, and the kind of old-school pepperoni that curls at the edges. It is the go to for sheet pizzas and broasted chicken when you are feeding a crowd after a game or gathering.
02
Best carryout classic
Kraus' Pizza – Massillon
West Massillon, An Easy Drive From Brewster • Carryout-Focused Hometown Shop • Best For Takeout Night
Square cut pizza with a slightly sweet sauce and plenty of cheese, built for grab-and-go dinners.
Kraus' is one of those Stark County names people grew up with, and the Massillon location is close enough to be a regular Brewster option. The pizza leans toward a sweet red sauce, edge to edge cheese, and crust that stays sturdy under extra toppings. Call ahead, swing through for your boxes, and you are set for a low key movie or game night at home.
03
Best for loaded specialty pies
Gionino's Pizzeria – Massillon
Massillon, North Of Brewster • Neighborhood Pizza And Chicken Joint • Great For Big Groups And Game-Day Spreads
Topping heavy pizzas and fried chicken buckets that can feed a whole crew without much planning.
Gionino's in Massillon is a popular choice when you want more than just a plain cheese or pepperoni. The menu leans into specialty pies piled high with meats, veggies, and extra cheese, plus their well known fried chicken and jojo potatoes. It is a smart one stop order for parties, team dinners, or any time you need a mix of pizza and hearty sides.
04
Family-friendly chain standby
Pizza Hut – Navarre
Navarre Shopping Strip • Sit-Down National Pizza Chain • Best For Families And Picky Eaters
Familiar pan pizzas, stuffed crusts, and pastas that keep everyone at the table happy.
For many Brewster families, the Navarre Pizza Hut is the easy answer when nobody can agree on what to eat. You get the classics people expect, from buttery pan crust to stuffed crust, wings, and pasta trays. It is a straightforward spot for a casual dine in meal or a big carryout order when you want something predictable and kid friendly.
05
Late-night delivery pick
Domino's Pizza – Massillon
Massillon Delivery Zone That Reaches Brewster • Fast-Delivery Pizza Chain • Best For Late-Night Cravings
Quick, customizable pizzas and sides that show up hot when smaller shops are closed.
When it is late, the weather is bad, or you just do not feel like leaving the house in Brewster, Domino's in Massillon is the reliable button to push. The online ordering is straightforward, with tons of options for crust, sauces, and toppings plus sides like bread twists, wings, and desserts. It is not trying to be artisan pizza, but it nails speed and consistency when that matters most.