01
Classic village staple
Little Sicily's Pizza
In The Village Of Brice • Old-School Columbus-Style Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A longtime Brice mainstay turning out thin, square-cut pies loaded with toppings and plenty of nostalgia.[4]
Little Sicily's feels like the kind of pizza place every small town wishes it had: straightforward, affordable, and consistently satisfying.[4] The menu leans into classic Columbus-style pizza with a crispy crust, edge-to-edge toppings, and generous cheese, plus subs and wings for rounding out a family order.[4] It’s an easy go-to when you want something close to home that everyone at the table already trusts.[4]
02
Best for big groups
Grapevine Pizza & Cafe
Refugee Road Corridor • Casual Family Pizza Restaurant • Great For Teams And Families
A roomy east-side spot known for large pizzas, pasta, and subs that work well for teams and family gatherings just a short hop from Brice.[1]
Grapevine Pizza & Cafe sits on Refugee Road and has long been a go-to for east-side families who need to feed a crowd without overthinking it.[1] Pizzas come in generous sizes with plenty of topping combos, and the menu’s pastas, salads, and subs make it easy to satisfy mixed tastes around the table.[1] With a relaxed, kid-friendly vibe and dependable service, it’s the place you book after games or grab when you’re hosting at home in Brice.[1]
03
Iconic east-side pie
Vick's Gourmet Pizza
Reynoldsburg Town Center • Neighborhood Tavern And Pizza Pub • Best For A Laid-Back Night Out
Reynoldsburg’s long-running tavern-style pizzeria, serving crispy, party-cut pies alongside cold drinks in a cozy, no-frills setting.[5]
Vick's Gourmet Pizza has been a Reynoldsburg fixture for decades, and it shows in the steady stream of regulars who treat it like a second living room.[5] The pizza leans tavern-style—thin, crispy, and party-cut—with classic toppings that taste best shared over a pitcher at one of the well-worn tables.[5] It’s worth the short drive from Brice when you want more of a night out than a simple carryout run.[5]
04
Delivery workhorse
Donatos Pizza – Brice Road Area
Brice Road Retail Strip • Fast-Casual Takeout And Delivery Shop • Top Pick For Quick Delivery
Edge-to-edge topping pies, fast service, and reliable delivery make this Donatos outpost a weeknight staple for Brice households.
For nights when convenience matters as much as flavor, the nearby Donatos on the Brice Road corridor is tough to beat. Their trademark thin crust and edge-to-edge toppings hold up well to delivery, and online ordering keeps things painless. It’s the spot locals keep in their favorites for last-minute game nights or busy weeknights when cooking is off the table.
05
Party-order specialist
Massey's Pizza – Reynoldsburg
Reynoldsburg Suburbs • Local Chain Known For Crispy Square-Cut Pies • Best For Feeding A Crowd
A trusted Columbus-area chain turning out crunchy, square-cut pizzas that shine when you order a couple of big boxes for a group.
Massey's in Reynoldsburg is a popular choice for Brice residents who like their pizza with a little extra crunch and plenty of pepperoni. The classic Columbus-style squares are easy to share, and the menu’s wings, salads, and subs make large orders simple to build out. When you’ve got coworkers, extended family, or the whole team to feed, this is a reliable, crowd-pleasing option within a quick drive.