01
Best overall pick
Natale's Pizzeria
In-Town Brilliant • Classic Ohio Valley Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Takeout
A small, no-frills shop turning out hearty, square-cut pies piled with toppings.
Natale's feels like the pizza many Brilliant locals grew up on: soft-but-crisp crust, plenty of cheese, and straightforward, satisfying toppings. Most people call ahead and grab their boxes to go, making it an easy weeknight or game-day option. Portions are generous, so a couple of pizzas usually feed a crowd without breaking the bank.
02
Most iconic style
DiCarlo's Pizza (Brilliant)
Riverside Brilliant • Counter-Serve Ohio Valley Slice Shop • Best For Quick Grab-And-Go
A classic Ohio Valley stop where hot crust and sauce meet cool cheese for that signature regional bite.
If you want to understand Ohio Valley pizza, the Brilliant DiCarlo's is a must. The pies come out with sauce and crust piping hot, then get finished with a layer of shredded cheese and toppings right before serving. It’s a simple counter setup with fast service, ideal when you’re passing through on Route 7 and want a few squares or a box to share.
03
Worth-the-drive legend
DiCarlo's Original Pizza
Downtown Steubenville • Old-School Ohio Valley Pizza Joint • Best For First-Timers To The Region
An Ohio Valley institution where generations have lined up for no-nonsense trays of square pizza.
The downtown Steubenville DiCarlo's is the spot longtime fans point to when they talk about how the style started. Expect a straightforward menu, a busy counter, and trays of square-cut pizza that disappear as quickly as they’re made. It’s a short drive from Brilliant, and the experience is as much about the local tradition as it is about the pizza itself.
04
Best family sit-down
Giannamore's Pizza
Wintersville Strip • Family Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria • Best For Relaxed Family Dinners
A cozy, family-run spot where you can linger over pizza, pasta, and a couple of extra baskets of bread.
Giannamore's in Wintersville is where many locals go when they want more than just a carryout box. The pizza leans comforting and saucy, with a menu that also covers familiar Italian-American favorites so everyone at the table finds something they like. It’s an easy choice for birthday dinners, after-church meals, or catching up with relatives from out of town.
05
Best for big appetites
Ray's Pizza
North End Steubenville • Neighborhood Pizza And Hoagie Shop • Best For Feeding A Crowd
A laid-back local joint known for hefty pies, loaded subs, and friendly, no-rush service.
Ray's feels like a true neighborhood standby, the kind of place where regulars get greeted by name and big orders are the norm. The pizza comes out sturdy and well-topped, built to handle extra cheese and meat without turning soggy. Add in wings, hoagies, and shareable sides, and it becomes a reliable option when you’ve got a houseful of hungry people just up the road from Brilliant.