01
Best overall pick
Jimmy Neno's Pizzeria & Taproom
Warren–Sharon Road Strip • Lively Taproom Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Craft Beer And Crisp Pies
A bustling taproom where thin, crisp pizzas share the spotlight with a strong beer lineup and friendly, small-town service.
Jimmy Neno's feels like the neighborhood living room, with locals filling the high-tops for game nights, casual dinners, and post-work meetups. The pies lean crisp rather than floppy, with plenty of edge-to-edge toppings and interesting specialty combinations that still feel approachable. Pair a pizza and wings with something from the tap list, and you’ll see why this is often the first place Brookfield residents recommend.
02
Classic hometown chain
Pizza Joe's Brookfield
Brookfield Center Crossroads • Takeout And Delivery Slice Shop • Go-To For Quick Takeout And Game Nights
A reliable hometown outpost turning out familiar pan pizzas, subs, and sheet pies ideal for feeding a crowd.
Pizza Joe’s is the spot you call when everyone’s already hungry and nobody wants to cook. The pan-style crust is soft but sturdy enough to handle extra cheese and toppings, and their sheet pizzas are a staple at parties, school events, and Friday movie nights. Expect straightforward, consistent pies at fair prices, plus wings and subs to round out a big order.
03
Worth-the-drive legend
Sunrise Inn of Warren
Downtown Warren • Old-School Italian Tavern • Iconic Spot For Brier Hill–Style Pizza
A Warren institution known for square-cut, pan-baked pies and classic Brier Hill pizza in a cozy tavern setting.
If you’re willing to drive a bit for a memorable pie, Sunrise Inn is the classic regional choice. Their square-cut pizzas come out of the oven bubbling and browned at the edges, with a sauce-forward profile that suits Trumbull County tastes. Try the Brier Hill pizza topped with peppers and grated cheese to get a feel for a style you rarely find outside the Mahoning Valley.
04
Big-flavor sheet pizza
Wedgewood Fernando's Pizza – Howland
Howland • Hearty Pan And Sheet Pizza Shop • Best For Feeding A Hungry Crew
Famous in the Youngstown–Warren area for thick, cheesy sheet pizzas loaded with toppings and a bold, zesty sauce.
Wedgewood Fernando’s is all about generous portions and old-school Mahoning Valley pizza energy. The crust is substantial without being doughy, built to hold serious amounts of cheese, pepperoni, and whatever else you want to pile on. It’s a favorite for team dinners, family gatherings, and any night when you want leftovers that will still taste great the next day.
05
Neighborhood staple
Cocca's Pizza Hubbard
Hubbard • Casual Neighborhood Chain Outpost • Best For Families And Mixed Orders
A friendly local chain location offering reliable pies, wings, and sides that keep both kids and adults happy.
Cocca’s in Hubbard is a comfortable middle ground when the group can’t quite decide what they want. The menu covers round and sheet pizzas, classic toppings, and a few specialty options, plus wings, salads, and sandwiches for non-pizza eaters. It’s the kind of spot where regulars know the staff, carryout is efficient, and you can count on a solid pizza every time.