01
Best overall pick
Dina's Pizza & Pub
Old Brooklyn • Lively Sports Bar & Pizzeria • Best For Game Nights
A Cleveland classic with hefty tavern-style pies, cold beer, and a packed, energetic dining room.
Dina’s is the kind of place you head to when you want pizza to feel like an event, not just takeout. The pies are generous, with a sturdy crust that holds up to plenty of toppings, and the cheese-to-sauce ratio leans comfort-food perfect. Add in lots of TVs, busy-but-friendly service, and plenty of room for groups, and it’s the go-to pick for watching the game after a quick drive up from Brooklyn Heights.
02
Best family-friendly classic
Antonio's Pizzeria LoSchiavo
Seven Hills • Family-Run Italian Pizzeria • Reliable Family Favorite
A long-running local chain known for its slightly crispy crust, sweet-leaning sauce, and big family-friendly dining room.
The Seven Hills location of Antonio’s is especially handy for Brooklyn Heights residents looking for a sit-down pizza night that still feels casual. Classic round pies, square-cut sheets, and a solid lineup of pastas and subs make it easy to keep everyone at the table happy. It’s the kind of dependable stop where servers recognize regulars and takeout is stacked high on busy weekends.
03
Best for big groups and late nights
Rascal House
Parma • Casual Counter-Service Pizza Joint • Late-Night Crowd Pleaser
Big, cheesy pizzas and shareable sides make this a go-to for hungry groups and post-game stops.
Rascal House leans into the old-school college-pizza vibe in the best way: wide pies, thick cheese, and plenty of toppings that don’t skimp. The Parma location is close enough for a quick run from Brooklyn Heights when you’re feeding a crowd or need something fast after a long day. Wings, wedges, and subs round out the menu, so you can cover every craving with one order.
04
Best quick slice stop
Geraci's Slice Shop
Ohio City • Retro By-The-Slice Shop • Quick City Detour
Classic New York–inspired slices with a crisp bottom, stretchy cheese, and a nostalgic corner-shop feel.
Geraci’s Slice Shop brings the long-loved east-side Geraci’s recipe to a fast, grab-and-go counter on the near west side. It’s ideal when you’re already heading toward the city from Brooklyn Heights and want a quick lunch or pre-bar slice. Expect foldable slices with a nicely browned crust, plus simple toppings done right and a fun, neon-accented interior that feels modern but unfussy.
05
Worth-the-drive destination
Angelo's Pizza
Lakewood • Bustling West-Side Pizza Institution • Destination Pie Experience
Hearty, cheese-laden pies and a lively dining room have made Angelo’s a must-try on the west side for decades.
Angelo’s is a bit of a drive from Brooklyn Heights, but many locals consider it a pilgrimage-worthy pizza night. The crust has a satisfying chew, the toppings are piled high, and specialty pies—like versions loaded with pepperoni cups or veggies—are easy crowd-pleasers. If you’re planning a weekend outing, expect a wait, but the quality of the pies and the buzzy Lakewood atmosphere more than justify the trip.