01
Ohio Valley icon
DiCarlo's Pizza - Bridgeport
National Road In Bridgeport, Just East Of Brookside • Ohio Valley Square-Cut Joint • Local Icon
The Bridgeport DiCarlo's is the go-to spot for that classic Ohio Valley square slice with cheese piled on after the bake.
If you ask around Brookside where to start with local pizza, this DiCarlo's location is almost always the first name you hear. The crust is crisp, the sauce leans tangy, and the fresh, just-melted cheese gives every slice a distinctive bite. Order a tray, grab a soda, and expect a steady stream of regulars picking up their usuals.
02
Hearty local favorite
Sha Nay Nay's Pizza
Neighborhood Streets Of Bridgeport Near Brookside • Hearty, Topping-Loaded Pies • Best For Big Appetites
Sha Nay Nay's turns out generously topped, old-school pies that feel tailor-made for game nights and family gatherings.
This is the spot for people who like a pizza that eats like a meal, with plenty of cheese and toppings that go right to the edge. The menu leans comforting and familiar, with crowd-pleasing combinations that travel well back to Brookside. Call ahead at busy times, because locals rely on it for weekend and game-day orders.
03
Family night standby
DeFelice Bros. Pizza - Martins Ferry
Martins Ferry Business District Along The River • Sit-Down Family Pizzeria • Best For Families
DeFelice Bros. in Martins Ferry offers a comfortable sit-down option with a broad menu and consistently crowd-pleasing pizza.
A short drive south from Brookside, this DeFelice location works well when you want more than a quick slice. The crust is soft but sturdy, with a balanced layer of sauce and cheese that suits a wide range of tastes. With wings, subs, and salads on the menu too, it’s an easy choice when a group can’t agree on just one thing.
04
Classic downtown slice
DiCarlo's Pizza - Wheeling
Downtown Wheeling Riverfront • Grab-And-Go Slice Shop • Quick Lunch Favorite
The downtown Wheeling DiCarlo's serves fast, ultra-classic Ohio Valley slices that are ideal for a quick bite across the river.
Cross the bridge from Brookside and you’re a few minutes from another beloved DiCarlo's counter in downtown Wheeling. It’s the kind of place where people duck in for a tray of slices on lunch break or before a game. The operation is streamlined and no-frills, but the pizza is exactly what regulars expect: hot, crisp, and straight to the point.
05
Chain with local reliability
Domino's Pizza - Bridgeport
Bridgeport Commercial Strip Along Us-40 • Fast-Delivery Chain Spot • Late-Night Delivery Pick
Bridgeport's Domino's is the reliable choice for late-night or last-minute pizza runs around Brookside.
While it’s a national chain, this Domino's sees plenty of local traffic thanks to its quick delivery reach into Brookside and nearby neighborhoods. The menu is familiar, from customizable hand-tossed pies to specialty combinations and stuffed cheesy bread. It’s the place you call when everything else has closed but the pizza craving hasn’t gone away.