01
Best overall pick
Sarah's Pizza
Downtown Brookville • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Dine-In
A longtime Brookville staple known for friendly service and classic, customizable pies.
Tucked just off the main drag, Sarah's feels like the kind of place that’s been part of town forever, in the best possible way. Expect well-topped pizzas with a crispy edge, straightforward salads, and a staff that is used to seeing the same faces week after week. It’s an easy choice when you want a relaxed sit-down meal that still feels very local.
02
Go-to delivery classic
Pizza Hut
North Brookville Near Wolf Creek • Familiar National Chain • Best For Easy Delivery And Carryout
A reliable stop for pan pizzas, wings, and value deals when convenience matters most.
Brookville’s Pizza Hut covers the bases for busy nights: quick online ordering, predictable pies, and plenty of combo specials. The menu runs the full chain lineup, from stuffed crust to breadsticks and wings, so it’s simple to keep a group of kids or coworkers fed. It’s not the most adventurous option in town, but it’s hard to beat for sheer convenience.
03
Best for big groups
Marion's Piazza
Englewood By I-70 • Dayton-Style Thin-Crust Pizzeria • Regional Favorite For Gatherings
A spacious Dayton-area institution serving square-cut thin-crust pies piled high with toppings.
Marion's Piazza in Englewood is a short drive from Brookville and worth it if you’re feeding a crowd. Their signature ultra-thin crust, edge-to-edge toppings, and square-cut slices make sharing easy, whether it’s a team party or a family reunion. The roomy dining area and fast service are geared toward groups who want to spread out, linger, and order a second round without breaking the bank.
04
Old-school Dayton classic
Cassano's Pizza King
Central Englewood • Old-School Pizza Pub • Best For Nostalgic Pizza Night
A long-running local chain turning out cracker-thin crust, loaded toppings, and retro pizza-parlor vibes.
Cassano's in Englewood delivers that throwback Dayton-style pizza experience many locals grew up with. The crust is thin and crisp, the toppings are generous, and the flavor leans pleasantly salty and savory, especially on their classic deluxe combinations. It’s a fun option when you’re in the mood for a nostalgic, low-key night out rather than something ultra-modern.
05
Fastest weeknight option
Domino's Pizza
Englewood Main Street Corridor • Carryout And Delivery Chain • Best For Late-Night Carryout
A quick-turnaround shop for customized pizzas, sandwiches, and sides with solid late-evening hours.
When you need something hot in a hurry, the Englewood Domino's is a dependable backup plan for Brookville households. The build-your-own options, frequent coupons, and tracking app make it especially handy for busy families juggling practices and meetings. It’s more about speed and flexibility than atmosphere, but it hits the spot when the priority is getting pizza on the table fast.