01
Local legend
Papa Oley's Pizza
Antwerp Village Center • Hearty, Family-Run Pizzeria • Best Overall Pick
Thick, cheesy pies and friendly small-town service make Papa Oley's a must-try for anyone near Broughton.
Papa Oley's is the kind of classic small-town pizzeria people will happily drive for, with generous toppings and a crust that’s substantial without being doughy. The dining room is simple and welcoming, and the menu leans into crowd-pleasers like loaded specialty pies and indulgent breadsticks. It’s a great choice when you want a relaxed night out that still feels like a treat.
02
Buffet crowd-pleaser
East of Chicago Pizza
Antwerp East Side • Buffet-Style Pizza And Salad Bar • Best For Families
A laid-back buffet setup and a wide range of toppings make this East of Chicago a reliable group spot.
If you’ve got a hungry crew, the East of Chicago in Antwerp is hard to beat for value and variety. Expect pan-style pizzas, stuffed crust options, and a rotating mix of specialty pies alongside a basic salad bar. It’s casual, easygoing, and ideal when no one can agree on just one kind of pizza.
03
Old-school favorite
Bud's Restaurant & Pizza
Downtown Defiance • Old-School Tavern And Pizza Joint • Best Sit-Down Meal
A Defiance standby, Bud's serves classic pizzas in a cozy, lived-in space that feels straight out of another era.
Bud's is the spot you pick when you want more than just a quick slice, pairing its pizzas with a full menu of casual comfort food. The pies lean classic—think crispy edges, plenty of cheese, and straightforward toppings done right. It’s an easy recommendation for a relaxed evening that still feels distinctly local.
04
Takeout workhorse
Marco's Pizza
North Defiance Commercial Strip • Carryout And Delivery Chain • Best For Weeknight Takeout
Marco's in Defiance is a go-to for consistent, sauce-forward pies when you just want to grab a box and head home.
This Marco's leans into the chain’s strengths: a flavorful sauce, chewy crust, and plenty of customizable topping combinations. It’s especially handy for Broughton-area residents who are already in Defiance for errands and want dinner sorted in one stop. Order ahead for quick pickup or opt for delivery if you’re staying closer to town.
05
Familiar favorite
Pizza Hut
Van Wert Commercial Strip • National Pizza Chain With Dine-In • Most Familiar Choice
Van Wert’s Pizza Hut offers the classic pan pizzas and breadsticks many locals grew up with, plus a straightforward dine-in option.
When you want exactly what you expect—thick pan crust, stuffed crust options, and those nostalgic breadsticks—the Pizza Hut in Van Wert fits the bill. It’s a comfortable choice for families who like a sit-down meal but still want something fast and predictable. Pair a couple of specialty pies with wings and you’ve got a dependable road-trip stop or weekend dinner from Broughton.