01
Best overall pick
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill
Wapakoneta • Family-Friendly Sports Bar Pizzeria • Best For Groups And Game Days
Big, shareable pies, plenty of TVs, and a lively but kid-friendly vibe make Beer Barrel a go-to from Buckland.
If you want pizza to feel like an outing, this is the place: roomy booths, a full bar, and a menu that covers everything from loaded pizzas to wings and subs. Crusts lean hearty rather than delicate, with lots of cheese and generous toppings that suit big tables and hungry teams. It’s an easy meet-in-the-middle choice when friends are driving in from around the county.
02
Classic local tavern
Guarnieri's Pizzeria & Pub
St. Marys • Old-School Tavern Pizza And Pub • Best For Casual Nights Out
A cozy, low-key pub where the pizza tastes like small-town Ohio in the best way.
Guarnieri's leans into that old-school tavern feel: dimmer lights, cold beer, and pizzas that arrive hot on metal pans. The crust is straightforward and sturdy, built to hold plenty of toppings without getting soggy. It’s the kind of spot locals use for simple, no-rush dinners after work or a lake day, with pizza at the center of the table.
03
Fast delivery standby
Domino's Pizza
Wapakoneta • National Delivery Chain • Best For Late-Night Delivery
When convenience matters more than ambiance, Domino’s in Wapakoneta reliably gets hot pizza to Buckland fast.
This is the dependable option for weeknights, late study sessions, or when everyone suddenly wants pizza at the same time. The menu is familiar—hand-tossed and thin-crust pies, stuffed cheesy breads, wings, and desserts—with lots of mix-and-match deals. It’s less about lingering over a meal and more about knowing dinner will land on the table without much planning.
04
Party pizza favorite
Fat Jack's Pizza
Lima • Carryout And Delivery Pie Shop • Best For Feeding A Crowd
Known for big, loaded pies, Fat Jack’s is a smart choice when you’re hauling pizza back to Buckland for a crowd.
Portions are the main story here: hefty pizzas with plenty of cheese and toppings, plus options like breadsticks and wings to round out a spread. Crust tends to be on the thicker, chewier side, which travels well on the drive back toward Buckland. It’s an especially good fit for birthday parties, game-day spreads, and any night when one pizza just won’t be enough.
05
Neighborhood takeout pick
Padrone's Pizza
Cridersville • Small-Town Carryout Pizzeria • Best For Quick Family Takeout
A straightforward, small-town shop that focuses on classic pies done right and ready to go.
Padrone’s keeps things tight and practical: a familiar lineup of pizzas, subs, and sides with a focus on prompt carryout and delivery. The crust skews toward classic Midwest—neither ultra-thin nor overly thick—with a good balance of sauce and cheese. It’s the kind of place Buckland families lean on for quick Friday-night dinners without a long drive or big production.