01
Best overall pick
Wally's Pizza
Cambridge • Old-School Ohio-Style Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A Cambridge standby serving generous, square-cut pies that feel made for game nights and big tables.
Wally's is the place locals name first when you ask where to get pizza around Buffalo. The crust is sturdy but not too thick, the toppings are loaded on, and the pies come cut in party-style squares that make sharing easy. It’s an ideal stop when you’re heading into Cambridge and want a classic, small-town pizza experience.
02
Best for delivery from Byesville
Plus One Pizza
Byesville • Local Delivery-Focused Shop • Best For Customizable Pies
A handy Byesville option with build-your-own pizzas and hearty specialty combinations delivered fast.
Plus One Pizza in Byesville is a go-to for Buffalo-area residents who want delivery without driving into Cambridge. The menu leans into heavy, topping-packed pizzas and classic sides like wings and cheesy bread, so it’s easy to feed a crew. It’s especially useful on weeknights when you want something satisfying and straightforward brought right to your door or close by.
03
Best late-night option
Domino's Pizza
East Cambridge • National Delivery Chain With Carryout • Best For Late-Night Orders
Reliable, quick-turn pies and sides that cover you when the craving hits after most local spots have closed.
Domino’s in Cambridge is less about atmosphere and more about convenience for Buffalo and the surrounding townships. The online ordering and tracking make it easy to time your pickup or delivery, and the menu goes far beyond basic pepperoni, with stuffed crusts, chicken, and desserts. It’s the pick when you value speed, consistency, and late hours over lingering at a table.
04
Best family sit-down
Pizza Hut
South Cambridge • Sit-Down Family Pizza Restaurant • Best For Families And Groups
Familiar pan pizzas and a sit-down setup that works well for family dinners and team celebrations.
The Pizza Hut in Cambridge is an easy meeting point if you’re bringing kids in from Buffalo or wrapping up a day in town. Thick, buttery pan crust and stuffed-crust options keep everyone happy, and the booths and big tables make it comfortable to stretch out with a crowd. It’s a dependable choice for birthday outings, after-game meals, or any night when you want pizza and plenty of refills without overthinking it.
05
Best value pick
Little Caesars Pizza
North Cambridge • Quick Counter-Service Chain • Best For Budget-Friendly Carryout
Grab-and-go pizzas at a price that makes last-minute takeout easy on the wallet.
Little Caesars in Cambridge is the practical choice for Buffalo residents who prioritize cost and speed. Hot-and-ready pies mean you can be in and out in a few minutes, which is handy when you’re just passing through town or feeding a hungry group on short notice. It may not be a lingering dinner spot, but for fast, inexpensive pizza to haul back home, it does the job well.