01
Best overall pick
LaRosa's Pizzeria Mt. Orab
Along Sr 32 In Mt. Orab • Cincinnati-Style Family Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Sit-Down Pizza
A roomy, family-friendly LaRosa's outpost that’s an easy weeknight drive from Buford.
This LaRosa’s sits right off the highway, with plenty of booths and big tables for families and ball teams. The menu leans into Cincinnati-style comfort—think sweet-leaning red sauce, customizable crusts, and plenty of toppings, plus hoagies and pastas if someone’s not in a pizza mood. It’s the kind of place where service is quick, kids are welcome, and sharing a big pie feels like the default order.
02
Best buffet-style option
Snappy Tomato Pizza Mt. Orab
Mt. Orab Shopping Strip Off Sr 32 • Casual Pizza Buffet And Carryout Spot • Best For Big Appetites
Snappy Tomato pairs a laid-back buffet with crowd-pleasing pies and salad bar basics.
If you’re feeding a hungry group after a game or practice, Snappy Tomato’s buffet makes ordering simple—everyone grabs a plate and goes back for their favorite slices. The crust runs on the softer, doughier side with plenty of cheese, and you’ll usually find a mix of classic toppings plus a few specialty pies in the rotation. Add in a basic salad bar and friendly, no-frills service, and it’s easy to see why locals keep it in the weeknight lineup.
03
Classic chain comfort
Pizza Hut Hillsboro
North High Street In Hillsboro • Classic American Pizza Chain Restaurant • Best For Families
The Hillsboro Pizza Hut is the dependable choice when you want familiar pan pizza and a sit-down meal.
This location keeps the classic Pizza Hut feel alive—red-roof nostalgia, big red cups, and plenty of booths. The signature pan crust, breadsticks, and wings are the main draw, and it’s an easy spot to take kids without overthinking the menu. For Buford residents, it’s a quick drive into town when you want something predictable, hot, and reasonably priced.
04
Fast delivery pick
Domino's Pizza Hillsboro
Uptown Hillsboro Corridor • Delivery-Focused Chain Pizzeria • Best For Last-Minute Pizza
Domino’s in Hillsboro is the go-to when you want hot pizza delivered out toward Buford in a hurry.
With its emphasis on online ordering and quick turnaround, this Domino’s is built for carryout and delivery nights. The menu covers everything from hand-tossed and thin crusts to stuffed cheesy bread, wings, and pasta bowls, so it’s easy to satisfy different cravings without multiple stops. It’s the kind of place you bookmark in your phone for those evenings when cooking is off the table and you just want something reliable on the doorstep.
05
Worth-the-drive destination
Joe's Pizza Napoli
Historic Downtown Milford • Wood-Fired Neapolitan-Style Pizzeria • Best Artisan Pies
Joe’s Pizza Napoli is a serious step up, serving blistered, wood-fired pies in a cozy Milford storefront.
For a special pizza night, many folks are happy to make the longer drive from Buford to Joe’s. Pies come out of the wood-fired oven with leopard-spotted crusts, simple toppings, and that tender, chewy center you expect from Neapolitan-style pizza. Pair it with a salad, a glass of wine or a craft soda, and a stroll through downtown Milford, and you’ve turned dinner into a full evening out.