01
Best overall pick
Johnny's Grill and Pizzeria
Burton Village • Small-Town Grill And Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A classic Burton hangout turning out generously topped pies alongside burgers and wings.
Johnny's feels like the kind of place where everyone behind the counter knows your name and the pizzas land on the table still bubbling. The crust is a straightforward hand-tossed style that stands up well to heavier toppings, with plenty of cheese and a solid red sauce. It is especially popular on game nights, so plan on a bit of a wait during Friday dinner rush.
02
Best for late-night delivery
Domino's Pizza
Along West High Street • Familiar National Delivery Shop • Fast, Reliable Delivery
Chain standby for consistent pies, loaded specialty pizzas, and weeknight deals.
When you want pizza with minimal effort, Burton's Domino's is the dependable move, especially for late-night or bad-weather cravings. The menu leans into build-your-own combinations, stuffed cheesy breads, and crowd-pleasing specialty pies that travel well. Order ahead online to take advantage of coupons and keep an eye on the tracker while you set the table.
03
Best for game night
Capps Pizza
Short Drive To Newbury Along Route 87 • Family-Run Carryout And Delivery Spot • Best For Big Groups
Hearty, cheese-forward pies with plenty of shareable sides.
A few minutes west of Burton, Capps in Newbury is a go-to when you are feeding a crowd. The pizzas are all about generous toppings and a slightly thicker crust that holds up well on larger sheet pies. Round out a game-day spread with wings, JoJo-style potatoes, and a couple of dipping sauces for the crusts.
04
Best tavern vibe
Zeppe's Tavern & Pizzeria
Newbury Township • Tavern-Style Pizzeria With Full Bar • Best For Pizza And A Beer
Crisp-edged pies served in a casual tavern with plenty of TVs and draft choices.
Zeppe's in Newbury is where many locals head when they want to sit down for pizza rather than grab a box to go. The crust tends to be on the thinner, crisper side, with classic toppings and a few loaded specialty combinations that pair well with a cold beer. It is an easy choice for meeting friends after work or catching a game without driving all the way into the city.
05
Best sauce lovers' pick
Gionino's Pizzeria
Middlefield Village • Neighborhood Takeout And Delivery Chain • Worth The Short Drive
Bold, garlicky pies and classic JoJo potatoes that feel made for small-town Ohio.
About ten minutes from Burton, the Middlefield Gionino's rewards the drive with a punchy red sauce and garlicky crust that fans swear by. Toppings run generous, so even a simple pepperoni and cheese feels substantial, and the square-cut pies are easy to share. Do not skip an order of fried chicken and JoJos if you are feeding a mixed crowd of pizza and non-pizza eaters.