01
Best small-town classic
Fast Eddie's Pizza
Bellville • Laid-Back Small-Town Pizzeria • Best For Families
A cozy Bellville standby serving hearty pies and subs just a short drive west of Butler.
Fast Eddie's feels like the kind of no-fuss neighborhood spot every small town hopes to have, with friendly staff and pizza that leans generous on cheese and toppings. It’s an easy choice when you want a casual sit-down meal after a day on the road or the trails. The menu covers all the basics—pizzas, subs, and sides—so everyone in the group can find something they like.
02
Best for thick-crust cravings
East of Chicago Pizza
Loudonville Near Mohican • Pan-Pizza And Buffet-Style Spot • Best For Groups And Teams
A Loudonville favorite known for its thick pan pizzas and customizable crusts, convenient to Mohican and Butler.
East of Chicago in Loudonville is a go-to when you're feeding a hungry crowd, whether it’s a family gathering or a youth sports team coming off the field. The signature pan crust and specialty pies offer more heft than your average slice, and the ability to tweak sauces and crust styles keeps regulars coming back. It’s a practical, kid-friendly option when you’re bouncing between Butler, Mohican, and the river.
03
Best old-school parlor
Leaning Tower of Pizza
Central Mansfield • Old-School Thin-Crust Pizza Parlor • Local Favorite
A long-running Mansfield institution serving crisp, thin-crust pies with a classic neighborhood feel.
Leaning Tower of Pizza has the well-worn charm you only get from decades of slinging pies to the same community. Expect crackly thin crust, straightforward toppings, and a sauce that leans savory rather than sweet, all served in a relaxed, throwback dining room. It’s worth the drive from Butler when you’re in the mood for a sit-down pizza night that feels rooted in local tradition.
04
Best for variety
Two Cousin's Pizza & More
Downtown Mansfield • Casual Pizza, Subs, And Pasta Shop • Best All-Around Crowd-Pleaser
A reliable downtown Mansfield option with pizzas, subs, and pasta that make ordering for a mixed group easy.
Two Cousin's lives up to the "& More" in its name, pairing solid pizzas with a long list of subs, pasta dishes, and sides. That range makes it a smart pick when not everyone in your group is set on pizza, or when you want to round out the pie with wings and garlic bread. It’s an especially handy stop if you’re in Mansfield for errands or an event and want to bring a box back to Butler.
05
Best pizza-and-chicken combo
Gionino's Pizzeria
South Mansfield • Takeout-Focused Regional Chain • Best For Takeout Nights
A popular regional chain location pairing classic Ohio-style pizza with fried chicken and jojo potatoes.
Gionino's in Mansfield is built for easy takeout, with phone-ahead and online orders that make weeknight dinners painless. The pizza hits all the regional notes—plenty of cheese, square-cut slices, and hearty topping combos—while the chicken and jojos turn it into a full meal. It’s a convenient option when you’re driving back toward Butler and want to grab everything for the evening in one stop.