01
Best overall pick
DiAngelo's Pizza
Just Off West Market Street • Sit-Down Italian Pizzeria • Go-To Family Dinner Spot
Hearty, old-school pies and generous portions make DiAngelo's the first name that comes up when locals plan a pizza night.
DiAngelo's leans into classic comfort: sturdy crusts, plenty of cheese, and toppings piled high alongside subs, pasta, and salads. The dining room is relaxed enough for kids and teams after a game, but it’s just as popular for carryout and delivery on weeknights. Call ahead on busy evenings, because the regulars know it’s worth the wait.
02
Best for late-night delivery
Domino's Pizza
East Cadiz • National Delivery Chain • Most Reliable Late-Night Option
When the craving hits late or the weather is lousy, the Cadiz Domino's is the go-to for fast, predictable pizza delivery.
This Domino's is all about convenience: online ordering, frequent deals, and delivery that reliably covers the village and nearby back roads. Build-your-own pies, specialty pizzas, wings, and desserts mean everyone can find something without overthinking it. It’s not trying to be gourmet, but for a movie night or quick team feed, it does the job every time.
03
Best for quick lunch
Pizza Express
Near The Main Highway • Fast-Casual Pizza Joint • Speedy Slice Stop
Pizza Express is the spot for a quick, hot pie made with fresh dough when you’re passing through or on a tight lunch break.
Known for dough made in-house and a straightforward menu, Pizza Express keeps things moving without feeling like generic fast food. The pizzas are sturdy and satisfying, with classic topping combos that appeal to kids and adults alike. It’s especially handy for grab-and-go orders when you don’t have time for a sit-down meal in town.
04
Best hidden gem
Johnny D's Pizza
West Of Downtown Cadiz • Takeout-Focused Pizzeria • Neighborhood Favorite
Johnny D's flies under the radar but wins people over with well-seasoned sauce, generous toppings, and friendly, no-nonsense service.
This small operation leans into what it does best: straightforward, well-made pies that taste like the kind of pizza you grew up with. Crusts have enough chew to hold up under plenty of toppings, and the sauce has more personality than most chain spots. It’s primarily a call-ahead, pick-up affair, making it a great choice for low-key nights at home.
05
Best cafe-style pies
Stairway Cafe
Downtown Cadiz • Cozy Cafe With Pizza And Comfort Food • Relaxed Hangout Spot
Stairway Cafe pairs its pizzas with a full cafe menu and a laid-back downtown setting that invites you to linger a little.
While Stairway Cafe isn’t a traditional pizzeria, its pies and flatbread-style pizzas are a pleasant surprise alongside burgers, sandwiches, and salads. The crust tends to be lighter, with toppings that skew a bit more creative than the typical corner pizza joint. It’s a good pick when not everyone in your group wants pizza but you still want a place where a well-made pie is on the table.