01
Best overall pick
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill
East Lima, Near I-75 • Lively Pizza And Sports Bar • Best For Groups And Game Nights
Big, crowd-pleasing pies, plenty of TVs, and a long menu make Beer Barrel an easy choice when everyone wants something different.
From Cairo, Beer Barrel is one of the first spots you reach once you hit Lima, and it feels built for meetups after work or school. The pizzas are generous, with lots of topping combos and a thick, satisfying crust, but you can also round out the table with wings, subs, and appetizers. It’s a comfortable, noisy room where you can watch the game, split a large specialty pie, and not feel rushed.
02
Old-school classic
Leaning Tower of Pizza
West Lima • Retro, Dine-In Pizzeria • Classic Local Favorite
A throwback pizza parlor with longtime regulars, thin, crispy-edged pies, and the kind of cozy booths you linger in.
Leaning Tower of Pizza has been on Lima pizza shortlists for years, and it’s the place people mention when they talk about growing up in the area. Expect classic, edge-to-edge toppings on a thinner crust, plus simple salads and sandwiches that fit the no-frills, hometown vibe. If you want that ‘local institution’ feel rather than a chain experience, this is the stop to prioritize.
03
Go-to delivery pick
Fat Jack's Pizza
North Lima • Carryout And Delivery Shop • Best For Takeout
A regional favorite for thick, cheesy Ohio-style pies that travel well and hit the table piping hot back in Cairo.
Fat Jack's leans into hearty, topping-heavy pizzas that feel tailor-made for movie night at home. The menu covers all the usual suspects plus a few loaded specialty options, and their timing on carryout and delivery is a big part of the appeal for nearby small towns. Call ahead from Cairo, swing through Lima to grab your order, and you can be back home before the cheese even starts to cool.
04
Reliable chain choice
Marco's Pizza – Allentown Road
West Side Of Lima • Quick-Service Chain Pizzeria • Fast, Familiar Option
Consistent, customizable pies and quick turnaround make this Marco's a dependable stop on the way in or out of Lima.
This west-side Marco's is one of those places locals rely on for straightforward, no-drama pizza nights. You can build your own pie, opt for one of the specialty recipes, or add cheesy bread and wings without stretching the budget. It’s especially handy if you’re already running errands on the west end of town and want to bring something hot back up to Cairo.
05
Family night standby
Pizza Hut – Elida Road
Northwest Lima • Casual Dine-In Chain • Best For Kids And Casual Dinners
A familiar sit-down Pizza Hut with roomy booths, pan pizzas, and plenty of kid-friendly picks when you want an easy night out.
For many families north of Lima, this Pizza Hut is the default choice when nobody feels like cooking and the kids want their favorite crust. The dine-in setup means you can settle into a booth, share a couple of large pans or stuffed crusts, and let everyone pick their own toppings. It’s not fancy, but the predictability and location make it a practical option for Cairo residents.