01
Best overall pick
JP's Pizzeria & Grill
Along Oh-170 In Calcutta • Casual Neighborhood Pizzeria And Grill • Local Favorite For Dine-In And Takeout
A small-town standby with hearty pizzas, friendly service, and enough on the menu to keep everyone at the table happy.
JP's feels like the kind of place where the staff knows regulars by name and remembers their usual order. The pizzas lean generous on cheese and toppings, with a crust that lands between soft and crisp, making it easy to please a mixed group. With burgers, subs, and appetizers alongside the pies, it works just as well for a relaxed sit-down meal as it does for a quick carryout on your way home.
02
Go-to delivery option
Domino's Pizza
Near State Route 170 Shopping Centers • National Delivery Chain Pizzeria • Fastest Delivery Bet
A reliable choice when you want hot pizza at your door fast, with plenty of crust styles and toppings to mix and match.
Set just off the main Calcutta commercial strip, this Domino's is all about convenience: online ordering, quick bake times, and efficient pickup. It shines for busy weeknights, game-day orders, and late homework sessions when nobody wants to cook. The mix of classic hand-tossed pies, specialty combinations, wings, and stuffed breads makes it easy to feed a crowd without much planning.
03
Chain alternative nearby
Papa Johns Pizza
Saint Clair Avenue Corridor In East Liverpool • Carryout And Delivery Chain Shop • Best For Game-Night Orders
A short drive from Calcutta, this Papa Johns is a dependable pick for big, topping-loaded pizzas and bundle deals.
Just down the hill in East Liverpool, the Saint Clair Avenue Papa Johns is close enough to be in the regular rotation for Calcutta households. The menu centers on thickly topped pies, parmesan crust edges, and familiar sides like breadsticks and wings that cover all the game-night staples. Value-focused specials and easy online coupons make it especially practical when you are feeding several people without breaking the budget.
04
Classic local choice
Bosco's Pizza
Downtown East Liverpool • Old-School Local Pizza Joint • Best Old-School Vibe
A long-running East Liverpool favorite known for straightforward, satisfying pizzas that taste like hometown Ohio pizza should.
Bosco's feels like the kind of unfussy local shop that quietly keeps a loyal following year after year. The menu keeps the focus on classic pies with familiar toppings, plus a handful of simple sides that travel well. It is a nice option when you want something with a bit more local character than a chain, but still want predictable, crowd-pleasing flavors.
05
Short-drive standout
Italo's Pizza
North Side Of East Liverpool • Takeout-Focused Pizzeria • Best Value Takeout Pick
A popular regional pizzeria offering generous Ohio-style pies that make the quick drive from Calcutta worth it.
Italo's is the type of place locals recommend when you ask where to go beyond the usual chains. Pies tend to be well-loaded, with a crust that holds up on the drive back to Calcutta and reheats nicely the next day. If you are planning a movie night or feeding a few hungry teenagers, calling in an order here can stretch the pizza budget while still feeling like a treat.