01
Best overall pick
Plus 1 Pizza
Just Off Downtown Caldwell • Laid-Back Hometown Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A Caldwell standby with classic pies, plenty of topping combos, and an easygoing small-town vibe.
Plus 1 Pizza is the kind of place where regulars have a go-to order and the staff usually remembers it. The crust leans hearty without being too heavy, with enough chew to stand up to their generous toppings. It’s a reliable choice for everything from a casual Friday night to feeding a crew after a local ballgame.
02
Best local classic
Wally's Pizza & Subs
Miller Street In Caldwell • Pizza-And-Subs Counter Spot • Best For Families
Neighborhood-style pies and hearty subs make Wally’s a go-to when you need to please a mixed crowd.
Wally’s feels like a proper small-town staple, with a menu that covers everything from loaded pizzas to toasted subs and sides. The pizza leans comfort-food classic—plenty of cheese, a sauce with a little sweetness, and topping combos that don’t overcomplicate things. It’s an easy pick for family takeout when everyone wants something a bit different but you only want to make one stop.
03
Best for late-night delivery
Domino's Pizza
West Street In Caldwell • National Delivery Chain • Best For Delivery
Fast, predictable, and open later than most local spots, Domino’s is Caldwell’s safety-net pizza option.
Domino’s in Caldwell does exactly what locals expect: gets hot pizza to your door quickly with plenty of customization. From hand-tossed to thin crust, plus wings, bread twists, and the occasional coupon deal, it’s built for busy nights when cooking isn’t happening. If you’re hosting a group or need a late-ish bite after a long drive, this is the easiest phone call to make.
04
Worth-the-drive sit-down spot
Guido's Pizza & Spaghetti House
North On I-77 In Cambridge • Old-School Italian Pizza Parlor • Dine-In Favorite
A classic red-sauce joint with pan pizzas and pasta that make the short drive from Caldwell feel worthwhile.
Guido’s has the cozy, slightly retro feel you want from a longtime pizza-and-pasta house, with big booths and pies that land in the middle of the table to share. The crust runs on the thicker side, with a crisp edge and plenty of cheese bubbling on top. It’s a popular choice for nights when you’d rather linger over a meal than rush home with a cardboard box.
05
Best quick-stop road-trip pie
Creno's Pizza
Just North In Byesville • Takeout-Focused Regional Chain • Grab-And-Go Pick
Square-cut, topping-heavy pies make Creno’s a handy stop when you’re cruising up or down I-77.
Creno’s is known for its no-nonsense, Ohio-style pizza: sturdy crust, edge-to-edge toppings, and party-cut slices that are easy to share. It’s a favorite with drivers and locals alike thanks to quick turnarounds and consistent pies. If you’re already out of town or passing through, it’s an easy detour for a box to bring back to Caldwell.