01
Best overall pick
Wedgewood Pizza (Boardman)
Boardman, South Of Youngstown • Classic Mahoning Valley Pan Pizza Shop • Go-To For Thick, Cheesy Pies
A Youngstown‑area institution known for square, cheese‑blanketed pies with a crispy edge and plenty of toppings.
If you ask locals where to start with area pizza, Wedgewood in Boardman is one of the first names you’ll hear. The crust is sturdy but soft inside, supporting generous layers of cheese and toppings that run right to the rim. Call ahead on busy nights—game days and weekends can mean a bit of a wait, but most people around Campbell will tell you it is worth it.
02
Family-friendly classic
Cocca's Pizza (Struthers)
Struthers, Minutes From Campbell • Casual Neighborhood Pizzeria • Best For Big Groups And Game Nights
Straightforward, crowd‑pleasing pizza with plenty of options and a friendly small‑town feel.
The Struthers location of Cocca’s is a convenient go‑to when you want to feed a lot of people without overthinking it. The menu leans into classic favorites—pepperoni, sausage, and sheet pizzas for parties—with a crust that lands between thin and thick. It is an easy hop from Campbell, especially when you are grabbing a few boxes before a game or family get‑together.
03
Old-school Italian spot
Belleria Pizza & Italian Restaurant (Struthers)
Struthers Riverfront • Sit-Down Italian Restaurant And Pizzeria • Best For A Relaxed Italian Dinner
Red‑sauce comfort food and substantial pizzas in a sit‑down setting that feels classic Mahoning Valley.
Belleria in Struthers is where you go when you want pizza but you also want a proper, lingering meal. Their pizzas come with a slightly thicker crust and plenty of sauce, but you can round things out with pasta, salads, and a carafe of pop for the table. It is a comfortable choice for families coming over from Campbell who want to make a night of it rather than just a quick pickup.
04
Pizza-and-wings favorite
Uptown Pizza (Boardman)
Boardman Commercial Strip • Lively Takeout And Dine-In Shop • Best For Pizza And Wings Combo Nights
Hearty pizzas paired with well‑liked wings, ideal when your crew wants a little bit of everything.
Uptown Pizza in Boardman has the kind of menu that makes game‑night ordering simple: solid pies, lots of wing sauces, and the usual sides. The pizza runs on the heartier side, with plenty of cheese and a crust that holds up well on the drive back toward Campbell. It is a practical option when you are feeding a mix of wing fans and pizza loyalists and want both to be good.
05
Downtown Youngstown pick
Avalon Downtown Pizzeria
Downtown Youngstown • Urban Bar-Style Pizzeria • Best For A Night Out In The City
A downtown spot mixing lively bar energy with well‑built pies and a few nods to local pizza traditions.
Avalon Downtown is a nice change of pace when you want pizza wrapped into a night out in Youngstown. The pies lean thinner with a bit of char, and the toppings list lets you go classic or more adventurous. It is an easy stop before or after a show downtown, and still close enough that Campbell locals treat it as part of their regular rotation.