01
Best overall pick
Crowtown Pizza
Downtown Coshocton • Small-Town Sit-Down Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Classic Pies
Crowtown Pizza is the cozy downtown spot locals point to first for a well-made, no-fuss pie and friendly service.
Set just off Main Street in Coshocton, Crowtown Pizza feels like the kind of small-town shop where they quickly learn your order. The menu leans into hearty, Midwestern-style pizzas with plenty of cheese and toppings, plus a few baked pasta and sandwich options to round things out. It is an easy, straightforward choice when you want to sit down, relax, and share a pie after a short drive in from Canal Lewisville.
02
Best takeout slice stop
Pizza Point
Central Coshocton • Carryout And Delivery Pizzeria • Best For Quick Takeout
Pizza Point is a small Coshocton shop known for its generous toppings and reliable carryout pies.
Tucked in among Coshocton’s in-town businesses, Pizza Point focuses on straightforward, well-topped pizzas that travel well back to Canal Lewisville. Expect classic Ohio-style pies with a slightly crisp crust, familiar toppings, and plenty of cheese for the price. It is a strong choice when you want to call ahead, grab your boxes, and be back home before the pizza has time to cool.
03
Best for loaded specialty pies
Plus 1 Pizza
Coshocton – Walnut Street Corridor • Classic Ohio-Style Pizza Shop • Great For Specialty And Loaded Pizzas
Plus 1 Pizza is a regional favorite in Coshocton for thickly topped specialty pies and easy delivery runs toward Canal Lewisville.
This Ohio-born mini chain has a devoted following in Coshocton for its hearty crusts and seriously loaded toppings. The menu runs from classic pepperoni to multi-topping specialty creations, so it is ideal when a group wants to experiment beyond the basics. With a focus on carryout and delivery, it fits perfectly for a stay-in pizza night just up the road from town.
04
Best for families and groups
East of Chicago Pizza
Coshocton – South Side • Family Pizza Buffet And Grill • Best For Families And Casual Groups
East of Chicago Pizza in Coshocton offers pan and thin-crust pies, wings, and a relaxed, family-friendly setup.
If you are feeding a crowd after a ball game or outing along the river, East of Chicago is one of the easiest choices around. The pan pizzas are thick and filling, while the thinner crusts and wings give everyone something to be happy about. With plenty of space and a casual atmosphere, it is the kind of place where no one has to worry about being too loud or too hungry.
05
Most reliable late-night option
Domino's Pizza
Coshocton – Near Main Commercial Strip • National Delivery And Carryout Chain • Late-Night And Last-Minute Pick
Coshocton’s Domino’s is the dependable choice for late-night or last-minute pizza runs from Canal Lewisville.
When other kitchens wind down, Domino’s keeps the ovens going with online ordering and quick delivery back toward Canal Lewisville. The menu is exactly what you expect from the chain: build-your-own pizzas, specialty combinations, and a roster of wings, breads, and desserts. It is not the most unique option in town, but it is the one you can count on when the craving hits after hours.