01
Classic New York slice
Bella Napoli Pizza and Pasta
Central Canfield • Cozy New York-Style Pizzeria • Best Overall Pick
A friendly, sit-down spot known for crisp New York-style pies and a full menu of comforting Italian favorites.
Bella Napoli feels like the kind of neighborhood place where the staff learns your order after a few visits. The pizza leans thin and foldable with plenty of cheese and classic toppings, but you can easily round out the table with pasta, salads, and appetizers. It’s an easy choice when you want a relaxed dine-in pizza night that still feels special.
02
Local institution
Inner Circle Pizza Canfield
Ironwood Boulevard Area • Lively Sports-Bar Pizzeria • Top Spot For Game Nights
A long-running local favorite pairing tavern-style pizza with a buzzy bar and plenty of TVs.
Inner Circle Pizza is the place locals suggest when you ask where to watch the game over a few pies. Expect sturdy, shareable pizzas with generous toppings, wings, and classic bar snacks that play well with a cold draft. The open layout and energetic atmosphere make it a natural fit for larger groups and casual meetups.
03
Carryout standby
Gionino's Pizzeria
East Main Street Corridor • Carryout And Delivery Pizzeria • Weeknight Takeout Favorite
A go-to counter-service spot for sauce-forward pies, cheesy sides, and quick pickup or delivery.
Gionino’s is built around convenience without shortchanging comfort food cravings. The crust has enough heft to handle loaded toppings, and the menu branches out into wings, subs, and their well-known fried chicken, so everyone at home can claim a favorite. Order ahead, swing through for a hot box, and dinner is handled with minimal effort.
04
Red-sauce comfort
Belleria Pizzeria
Route 224 Business Strip • Classic Italian-American Pizza Shop • Casual Family Choice
A straightforward, family-friendly shop serving thick, cheesy pies and familiar Italian-American staples.
Belleria leans into that comforting, red-sauce vibe the Youngstown area is known for. Pizzas come out substantial and cheesy, with crusts that hold up to extra toppings and plenty of sauce. It’s the kind of place where families split a couple of large pies, add an order of pasta or salad, and linger over refills without feeling rushed.
05
Chain standby
Papa Johns Pizza – Boardman Canfield Rd
Boardman-Canfield Road Corridor • National Delivery Chain Outpost • Reliable Late-Night Option
A familiar, fast option for customizable pizzas and sides when you need delivery on a busy night.
This Papa Johns location serves the Canfield area with the same build-your-own pies and specialty combinations you’d expect from the chain. It’s especially handy when you want predictable, consistent pizza delivered to your door, whether for a kids’ sleepover or a late study session. The range of sauces, crust styles, and extras like breadsticks and desserts makes it easy to feed a crowd on short notice.