01
Best overall pick
Cassano's Pizza King
Central Carlisle On Central Avenue • Classic Ohio Pizzeria With Thin, Square-Cut Pies • Local Standby
Carlisle’s home-base pizzeria, known for its cracker-thin crust and plenty of toppings.
If you ask around town where people actually order their Friday-night pizza, Cassano’s comes up fast. The crust is light and crisp, the toppings are generous, and the sheet pizzas make feeding a crowd easy. It’s an unfussy spot that nails the basics and delivers reliably hot, nostalgic-tasting pies.
02
Closest chain favorite
Marco's Pizza
Franklin, Just East Of Carlisle • Carryout And Delivery Chain With Chewy, Classic Crust • Weeknight Takeout Go-To
A quick hop from Carlisle, Marco’s is the reliable stop for consistent, customizable carryout pies.
When you want something easy on a busy weeknight, Marco’s in nearby Franklin is a practical choice. The menu runs from classic pepperoni to build-your-own pies with a hearty crust and well-seasoned sauce. Add in cheesy bread or wings and you’ve got a simple, crowd-pleasing spread without driving far.
03
Best for craft toppings
Dewey's Pizza
Austin Landing, South Of Miamisburg • Bustling Sit-Down Spot With Creative Specialty Pizzas • Destination Pick For Foodies
Dewey’s at Austin Landing is worth the short drive for inventive pies, fresh salads, and a lively dining room.
If you’re up for a little drive, Dewey’s rewards you with chewy, blistered crusts and toppings that go way beyond the usual. Think combos with goat cheese, roasted veggies, and flavor-packed sauces, backed up by big salads that are actually worth ordering. It’s a great choice when you want a night out rather than just a box on the coffee table.
04
Best small-town tavern feel
Ron's Pizza House
Historic Downtown Miamisburg • Old-School Pizza Pub With A Neighborhood Vibe • Laid-Back Family And Friends Spot
Ron’s serves classic, no-frills pizzas in a cozy, lived-in downtown setting that feels like a local hangout.
Downtown Miamisburg’s Ron’s Pizza House feels like the kind of place that’s been part of people’s routines for decades. The pizza is straightforward—crispy-edged crust, plenty of cheese, and a slightly sweet sauce—and you can linger over a pitcher and a pie without rushing. It’s an easy pick when you want a relaxed sit-down meal that still feels very local.
05
Best for big groups
LaRosa's Pizzeria
Middletown Near I-75 • Family-Friendly Regional Chain With Cincinnati-Style Pies • Group-Friendly Crowd-Pleaser
LaRosa’s in Middletown is a convenient meet-in-the-middle spot with plenty of seating and a broad menu.
For teams, birthday dinners, or extended family meetups, LaRosa’s is an easy option not far from Carlisle. The menu stretches from thin-crust and traditional pizzas to pastas, hoagies, and kid-friendly standbys. Service is geared toward handling groups smoothly, so everyone can share a few big pizzas and still find something that fits their preferences.