01
Best overall pick
Shirky's Pizza Zone
Downtown Carroll • Laid-Back Small-Town Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Dine-In And Carryout
A true Carroll staple, known for friendly service and generously topped pies right in the heart of the village.
If you want pizza without leaving Carroll, Shirky's is the obvious first stop. The crust leans classic Midwest—sturdy enough for lots of toppings but still soft at the center—and the menu covers all the comfort standards locals expect. It’s the kind of place where staff recognize regulars, making it an easy choice for a relaxed dinner or a casual pick-up order on the way home.
02
Best for big groups
Pizza Crossing
Tiki Lane Corridor, Lancaster • Bustling Sit-Down Pizza Restaurant • Go-To Spot For Hearty Pizzas And Gatherings
A Lancaster mainstay famous for thickly layered toppings and shareable pies that easily feed a crowd.
Pizza Crossing draws fans from all over Fairfield County for its substantial pizzas and lively atmosphere. The pies are built heavy on cheese and toppings, making them ideal for teams, large families, or anyone looking to split a few big pizzas at the table. It’s a solid bet when you want a sit-down meal with plenty of leftovers to take back to Carroll.
03
Best for delivery from Lancaster
Cristy's Pizza (Pierce Avenue)
Pierce Avenue Corridor, Lancaster • Carryout And Delivery-Focused Pizzeria • Reliable Choice For Quick Delivery And Late Dinners
A fast-moving shop known for consistent, made-to-order pies that travel well back to Carroll.
Cristy’s on Pierce Avenue specializes in efficient carryout and delivery, which makes it especially appealing for weeknights when you don’t feel like cooking. The crust is straightforward and crowd-pleasing, with plenty of topping combinations and classic sides like cheesy bread and wings. If you’re ordering for a mix of adults and kids, their predictable, not-too-fancy pies tend to keep everyone happy.
04
Best for families
Pizza Cottage
West Lancaster • Family-Friendly Pizza Restaurant • Comfortable Sit-Down Choice With Broad Appeal
A casual spot where families linger over shareable pizzas, salads, and appetizers in a relaxed setting.
Pizza Cottage offers a roomy, easygoing dining room that works well for family gatherings or meeting friends from around the county. The menu goes beyond pizza, with salads, subs, and appetizers that make it simple to satisfy different tastes at the same table. It’s worth the short drive from Carroll when you want a longer meal out rather than a quick pickup.
05
Best for specialty pies
Sugar Bears Pizzeria
Historic Downtown Lancaster • Cozy Neighborhood Pizzeria • Top Pick For Creative Toppings And Local Feel
A small, personality-filled shop that leans into flavorful specialty pizzas and a friendly, local crowd.
Sugar Bears appeals to pizza fans who like to branch out beyond basic pepperoni. Their pies often feature bolder topping combinations and plenty of cheese, giving the menu a more playful edge than some of the larger chains. It’s an easy add-on to a trip into downtown Lancaster and a fun change of pace from the more traditional spots closer to Carroll.