Carrollton • best pizza

5 Best Pizzerias & Pizza Places for Carrollton Ohio

Carrollton’s pizza scene leans cozy and unfussy, with a mix of old-school parlors and familiar chains along Canton Road and around the village square. From crispy thin pies to loaded thick-crust trays, there’s a slice for nearly every mood. These five spots are where locals actually pick up dinner after a ball game, a lake day, or a long shift.

 
01

Crossroads Pizza

Downtown Carrollton • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria • Local Favorite

A go-to downtown stop for generous pies, wings, and casual nights out with friends or family.

Crossroads Pizza feels like the definition of a Carrollton staple: big pizzas, friendly staff, and plenty of locals grabbing dinner after games or meetings. The crust leans hearty, with toppings piled on thick and wings that are almost as popular as the pies. It’s the spot you suggest when you want everyone to walk away full and happy.

02

Gionino's Pizzeria

Canton Road Corridor • Carryout And Delivery Shop • Go-To For Takeout

Known for its loaded pies and chicken, this is the reliable call when you’re feeding a crowd at home.

Gionino’s is a favorite for sheet pizzas, loaded toppings, and those big carryout orders that make weeknight dinners easy. The crust has a satisfying chew, and their signature sauce leans savory without being too sweet. Pair a couple of pizzas with their fried chicken and jojo potatoes and you’ve got a full spread ready for the whole crew.

03

Pizza Hut

Canton Road Strip • Casual Chain Pizzeria • Best For Families

A classic Pizza Hut with the expected pizzas, pastas, and wings, convenient for predictable, family-friendly meals.

Carrollton’s Pizza Hut is the spot for those nights when everyone just wants something familiar and easy. The menu sticks to the hits—pan pizzas, breadsticks, wings, and simple pasta dishes—so ordering for picky eaters is straightforward. It’s especially handy for takeout on busy evenings or quick lunches between errands on Canton Road.

04

Jimmy's Pizzeria

West Carrollton • No-Frills Hometown Spot • Best For Classic Slices

A modest local shop turning out straightforward, well-made pizzas that locals keep in their regular rotation.

Jimmy’s Pizzeria is the kind of low-key place you hear about from someone who grew up in town. The pies are simple in the best way—solid crust, balanced sauce, and toppings that feel more like home cooking than assembly-line. It’s a smart choice when you’d rather support a small neighborhood shop than grab another generic slice.

05

Domino's Pizza

Carrollton Outskirts • Fast-Delivery Chain Shop • Late-Night Pick

Quick, customizable pizzas and sides with tracking-friendly delivery when you need something hot in a hurry.

Domino’s is the reliable backup plan for late evenings, bad weather, or when nobody feels like leaving the house. The online ordering and tracker make it easy to customize everything from crust style to sauce and toppings. It’s not the most charming spot on this list, but it earns its place by being fast, predictable, and open when other kitchens are winding down.