01
Best overall pick
Old Scratch Pizza & Beer
Downtown Troy • Wood‑Fired Craft Pizzeria • Destination For Pizza Lovers
Inventive wood‑fired pies and a friendly, buzzy taproom vibe make Old Scratch a go‑to for Casstown pizza runs.
If you want pizza that feels a step above the usual carryout, Old Scratch is the place to aim for. The menu leans into charred, chewy‑crusted pies topped with everything from classic pepperoni to spicy hot honey drizzles and seasonal vegetables. Big communal tables and a solid beer list make it an easy spot for both family gatherings and casual nights out.
02
Classic thin‑crust choice
Marion's Piazza
South Troy Near I‑75 • Dayton‑Style Thin‑Crust Institution • Classic Dayton‑Style Experience
Paper‑thin crust, square‑cut pies, and a big, cavernous dining room deliver that old‑school Marion’s experience close to Casstown.
Marion’s is where you go when you’re craving that super thin, crispy crust that Dayton‑area folks swear by. The toppings are finely chopped and spread edge‑to‑edge, so every bite grabs a bit of everything. With plenty of seating and a casual, throwback feel, it’s especially handy for birthday parties, team dinners, and big family meet‑ups.
03
Sit‑down Italian pick
3 Joe's Pizzeria & Trattoria
Downtown Piqua • Family‑Run Italian Pizzeria • Best For A Relaxed Sit‑Down Meal
A cozy downtown spot where you can linger over hand‑tossed pies, pastas, and a glass of wine.
3 Joe’s feels like a proper trattoria, with a full Italian menu and pizzas that hold their own against the pastas and entrées. Crusts are a bit thicker and chewier here, with generous toppings and plenty of specialty combinations if you want to venture beyond pepperoni. It’s a nice choice when you want dinner to feel like an evening out rather than just a quick pickup.
04
Build‑your‑own favorite
Rapid Fired Pizza
Troy Retail Corridor • Fast‑Casual Build‑Your‑Own Spot • Best For Quick Custom Pies
Order your own creation, watch it zip through the oven, and be eating in just a few minutes.
Rapid Fired is the answer when everyone in the car wants something different on their pizza. You work your way down the line choosing sauces, cheeses, and toppings, and the individual‑size pies come out fast with nicely blistered crusts. It’s efficient enough for a quick lunch stop from Casstown but flexible enough to keep picky eaters happy.
05
Reliable takeout standby
Cassano's Pizza King
East Troy Neighborhood • Classic Carryout Pizza Joint • Reliable Weeknight Takeout
A long‑running local chain slinging ultra‑thin, square‑cut pies that feel tailor‑made for casual nights at home.
Cassano’s is the kind of place you keep on speed dial for busy weeknights or game‑day spreads. Its signature crust is crisp and almost cracker‑thin, with toppings chopped small and spread right out to the edge. It’s a no‑frills operation, but that’s part of the charm—just solid, familiar pizza that travels well back to Casstown.