01
Best overall pick
Cameo Pizza at Fast Eddie's
Catawba Peninsula Near The Marina • Lively Sports Bar With Classic Ohio Tavern Pizza • Go-To For Groups And Game Nights
A Catawba staple for crispy-edge pizzas, cold drinks, and wall-to-wall TVs on game day.
Cameo Pizza inside Fast Eddie's is where a lot of Catawba locals default when someone says, “Let’s just get pizza.” The crust lands in that sweet spot between crispy and chewy, with generous cheese and toppings that actually reach the edge. It’s loud, social, and ideal when you want to watch a game, share a few big pies, and not worry about anyone going home hungry.
02
Best for creative toppings
Sloopy's Pizza
Port Clinton East Side • Gourmet Specialty Pizzeria • Destination For Food-Focused Pizza Fans
Nationally recognized pies with inventive toppings make this worth the short drive from Catawba.
Sloopy’s is the spot you pick when you want pizza to feel like an event, not an afterthought. The menu leans heavily into specialty combinations, from loaded meat lovers to more adventurous builds with veggies, sauces, and drizzles you don’t see everywhere. It’s a fun place to share a couple of large pies, compare favorites, and see why it regularly shows up in “best pizza” conversations.
03
Best downtown vibe
The Brick House
Downtown Port Clinton • Brick-Walled Bar And Grill With Standout Pizza • Good For Pizza Plus Drinks
A downtown hangout where the brick-oven-style pies pair well with a full bar and live-leaning atmosphere.
The Brick House sits right in the middle of Port Clinton’s small downtown, making it an easy stop before or after a stroll along the water. The pizza has a hearty, pub-style feel, with plenty of cheese and toppings and crust that holds up to it all. It’s a solid choice if your group wants a place that feels more like a night out than a quick carryout stop.
04
Best neighborhood hangout
Bell Mell Pizza
Residential Side Of Port Clinton • Casual Neighborhood Pizza And Pub • Laid-Back Local Favorite
A low-key spot where locals grab thick, hearty pies and settle in for a relaxed evening.
Bell Mell has the easygoing feel of a place that’s been serving the same families for years. The pizzas are substantial, with a slightly thicker crust and plenty of cheese—ideal if you like a heavier, more old-school style. It’s not flashy, but if you’re after a comfortable, no-rush meal a short drive from Catawba, this is exactly that.
05
Best for fast carryout
Marco's Pizza
Port Clinton Commercial Strip • Chain Pizzeria Focused On Delivery And Carryout • Reliable Option For Quick Pizza Nights
A familiar name delivering consistent pies when you just want something good, hot, and easy.
Marco’s isn’t trying to be a destination; it’s the dependable pick when you’re back from the lake late and want dinner sorted with one call. Crust options, predictable toppings, and solid sides make it easy to keep everyone at the rental or campsite happy. If you’re staying near Catawba and planning a low-key night in, this is the stress-free move.