01
Best overall pick
Colonial Pizza
Downtown Cedarville • Small-Town Pizza Parlor • Local Favorite
The classic Cedarville pie shop locals grow up on and keep coming back to.
Set right on Main Street, Colonial Pizza is the spot where Cedarville students, families, and long-timers all end up for a laid-back slice night. The menu leans toward hearty, cheese-forward pies with plenty of classic toppings and a crust that hits a sweet spot between soft and crisp. It’s an easy go-to when you want familiar flavors, friendly service, and no fuss.
02
Most quirky and creative
Ha Ha Pizza
Downtown Yellow Springs • Bohemian Veggie-Friendly Pizzeria • Best For Adventurous Eaters
A Yellow Springs institution known for whole-wheat crusts, funky toppings, and a hippy-artsy vibe.
Just a short drive from Cedarville, Ha Ha Pizza packs big character into a cozy corner of downtown Yellow Springs. Expect inventive topping combos, plenty of vegetarian and vegan-friendly options, and crusts that feel more farmer’s market than fast food. It’s the kind of place where you linger over a pie, people‑watch on Xenia Avenue, and feel like you’ve stepped into a local tradition.
03
Best slice stop
Bentino's Pizza
South Yellow Springs • Casual Slice Shop And Delivery Joint • Best For Quick Bites
A laid-back spot for foldable slices, loaded subs, and easy takeout before or after a drive back to Cedarville.
Bentino’s offers a more straightforward, East Coast-leaning style of pizza with big, foldable slices and generous cheese. It’s especially handy if you’re in Yellow Springs for hiking at Glen Helen or John Bryan and want something filling without a long sit-down. Call ahead for a whole pie or pop in for a couple of slices and a drink to keep things simple.
04
Dayton-style classic
Cassano's Pizza & Subs
Xenia Towne Square Area • Old-School Dayton-Style Pizzeria • Best For Party-Cut Pies
A go-to for ultra-thin, square-cut pies piled edge-to-edge with toppings in nearby Xenia.
Cassano’s brings that distinct Dayton-style experience: a cracker-thin crust, loads of toppings right out to the rim, and tidy square cuts perfect for sharing. The Xenia location is an easy hop from Cedarville when you want something different from the usual college-town pizza. Pair a couple of large pies with their classic subs and you’ve got an easy solution for a hungry group.
05
Best for big groups
Marion's Piazza
Near Fairfield Commons In Beavercreek • Large Dine-In Family Pizzeria • Best For Families And Teams
A spacious destination for thin-crust pies, pitchers of soda, and big tables that can handle the whole crew.
If you’re willing to drive a bit farther from Cedarville, Marion’s Piazza in Beavercreek is built for gatherings. The menu centers on ultra-thin, square-cut pies with a nostalgic, Dayton-area feel, plus plenty of kid-friendly options. It’s a smart pick for team celebrations, church groups, or any night when you need lots of seats and food that arrives fast.