01
Best overall pick
Tuscany's Italian Restaurant
East Franklin Street • Classic Sit-Down Italian Restaurant • Local Favorite For Pizza And Pasta
A cozy, family-run Italian spot where the pizza is just as much of a draw as the pasta and house red sauce.
Tuscany's feels like the neighborhood Italian place every town wishes it had, with hand-tossed pies that come out bubbling and generously topped. The crust leans on the softer, chewier side, great for soaking up extra sauce, and the specialty combinations are hearty without being fussy. It’s an easy choice for a relaxed dinner when you want pizza, a glass of wine, and a proper sit-down meal in Centerville.
02
Best for big groups and carryout
Centerville Pizza
South Main Street Corridor • Carryout And Delivery Pizzeria • Go-To Game-Night Order
A no-nonsense local shop known for loaded pies, big orders, and a menu that can feed a whole crew.
Centerville Pizza is the place locals call when they’re feeding a houseful of people and don’t want to overthink it. The pizzas come cut into convenient squares with plenty of toppings all the way to the edge, and the menu stretches into wings, subs, and their well-known broasted chicken. It’s more about hearty, satisfying food than ambience, so think carryout, delivery, and casual nights in front of the TV.
03
Dayton-style legend
Marion's Piazza (Centerville/Washington Township)
Near Dayton Mall • Dayton-Style Thin-Crust Pizzeria • Best For Classic Party-Cut Pies
A sprawling, retro dining room serving ultra-thin, square-cut pies that many locals grew up on.
Marion's is practically an institution in the Dayton area, and the Centerville/Washington Township location keeps that tradition going with its signature cracker-thin crust. Pizzas arrive loaded with finely chopped toppings and cut into small squares, ideal for sharing around a big table. With its cavernous dining room, fast service, and nostalgic feel, it’s a natural fit for youth teams, birthday gatherings, and anyone chasing a true Dayton-style pie.
04
Best for craft night out
Old Scratch Pizza (Washington Township)
Miamisburg–Centerville Road • Casual Neapolitan-Style Pizzeria And Taproom • Best For Craft Beer And Wood-Fired Pies
A buzzy, industrial-chic spot turning out blistered, wood-fired pizzas alongside a strong craft beer list.
A quick drive from Centerville proper, Old Scratch’s Washington Township location is where pizza night feels a little more like a night out. The Neapolitan-style pies come with puffy, charred crusts and creative topping combinations that go well beyond the usual pepperoni-and-mushroom order. Long communal tables, an open kitchen, and a rotating tap list make it a favorite for date nights, after-work meetups, and anyone who treats pizza as a serious hobby.
05
Best quick slice
The Flying Pizza (Centerville)
Near Cross Pointe Center • New York-Style Slice Shop • Fast-Casual Lunch And Slice Stop
A low-key counter spot where you can grab oversized, foldable slices that hit the spot in minutes.
The Flying Pizza brings a bit of New York attitude to the Centerville area with its big, thin slices and classic toppings. It’s the kind of place where you walk up, point at what looks good in the case, and are eating a hot slice a couple of minutes later. With quick service and straightforward pies, it’s especially handy for lunch breaks, errands around Wilmington Pike and 675, or a low-fuss dinner on the go.