01
Best overall pick
ETalian
Downtown Chagrin Falls • Naples-Style Wood-Fired Pizzeria • Destination For Neapolitan Purists
ETalian turns out blistered, wood-fired individual pies just steps from the falls.
The menu leans into classic Naples-style combinations, with light, chewy crusts and toppings that taste fresh rather than overdone. It is an easy choice when you want something a little more polished than a typical slice shop but still casual enough for families and post-hike dinners. Grab a seat by the windows to watch the village go by with a margherita and an espresso or glass of wine.
02
Craft pizza & cocktails
Crumb & Spigot
Bainbridge / East Washington Corridor • Upscale Tavern With Artisan Pizzas • Best For Date Night
Crumb & Spigot pairs charred, cheffy pizzas with one of the better cocktail programs around Chagrin.
This stylish tavern is known as much for its bar as for its food, but the pizzas are quietly some of the best in the eastern suburbs. Expect creative toppings, nicely blistered crusts, and shareable pies that work well alongside small plates. It is the spot locals pick when they want pizza that feels like a night out, not just takeout.
03
Classic neighborhood pie
Pizzeria DiLauro
South Russell / Chillicothe Road • Traditional Italian-American Pizzeria • Takeout Staple
Pizzeria DiLauro is the kind of low-key shop that quietly becomes your default Friday-night pizza call.
The crust here hits that sweet spot between thin and doughy, sturdy enough for generous cheese and toppings without feeling heavy. It is straightforward, comforting pizza with a familiar Italian-American feel, plus pastas and wings if you are feeding a crowd. Call ahead, swing in, and you will understand why so many nearby households are regulars.
04
Hearty pies & ribs
Augie's Pizza & Ribs
Chagrin Falls Area • Casual Pizza And Rib Joint • Best For Big Groups
Augie's serves generous, classic pies alongside ribs and hearty sides that make it a one-stop spot for family dinners.
This is the place to go when you want plenty of food and no fuss, with square-cut pizzas loaded up in true Northeast Ohio fashion. The menu ranges from basic pepperoni to meat-heavy specialty pies, plus the ribs that gave the place its name. It is ideal for feeding a crowd after a game, a school event, or a lazy weekend afternoon.
05
Family-run favorite
Sirna's Pizzeria
Country Roads East Of Chagrin • Laid-Back Family Pizzeria • Local Family Favorite
Sirna's feels like a countryside pizza stop where the staff still remembers regular orders by heart.
Expect friendly service, straightforward pies, and that small-town pace that makes you want to linger an extra few minutes. The crust is sturdy and saucy, built to handle classic toppings without getting soggy, and the menu adds subs and salads to round out an easy weeknight meal. It is a good choice when you are driving in from the rural edges around Chagrin and want something close to home.