01
Best overall pick
Avalanche Pizza
East Athens Off East State Street • Creative Artisan Pizzeria • Destination For Adventurous Toppings
A go-to for big, boldly topped pies made with quality ingredients and plenty of personality.
Avalanche is the spot locals mention first when you ask where to get memorable pizza near Chauncey. About a 10-minute drive from the village, it leans into inventive flavor combos, generous toppings, and chewy, well-developed crust. It is an easy choice when you want something a little different than the usual chain pie.
02
Late-night slices
Goodfella's Pizza
Uptown Athens On Court Street • Walk-Up Slice Counter • Late-Night Campus Favorite
Classic, oversized New York-style slices served fast right in the middle of uptown Athens.
Goodfella's is the place students and night-shift workers hit for a hot slice after dark. The setup is simple: big foldable slices, straightforward toppings, and quick service right on Court Street. If you are coming down from Chauncey for an OU game or a night out, this is an easy, grab-and-go option.
03
Game-day hangout
Courtside Pizza
Near Ohio University Campus In Uptown Athens • Casual Sports-Bar Pizzeria • Best For Groups And Game Days
Laid-back pies, pitchers, and plenty of TVs make this a natural stop before or after OU events.
Courtside leans into the classic college-town pizzeria vibe, with big screens, pitchers, and shareable pizzas. The crust is on the thicker, heartier side, ideal when you are feeding a crowd from Chauncey or hosting visiting family. It is especially lively on weekends and during basketball or football season.
04
Family-friendly choice
Pizza Cottage
Commercial Strip Along East State Street In Athens • Sit-Down Family Pizzeria • Best For Families And Kids
A roomy, sit-down spot with plenty of topping choices, appetizers, and kid-friendly options.
Pizza Cottage is a comfortable pick when you want a full meal rather than just a quick slice. The menu goes beyond pizza with salads, subs, and appetizers, so everyone at the table finds something to like. It is a straightforward drive from Chauncey and works well for birthday dinners, team celebrations, or relaxed Sunday outings.
05
Reliable delivery pick
Donatos Pizza
Athens East State Street Corridor • Thin-Crust Delivery And Carryout Chain • Best For Easy Delivery And Takeout
Crispy thin-crust pies loaded edge-to-edge with toppings, ideal when you want dependable delivery to the Chauncey area.
Donatos is a regional favorite thanks to its signature thin crust and toppings spread all the way to the edge. For Chauncey residents, it is one of the more reliable options for consistent delivery on busy nights. The menu also covers wings, salads, and desserts, so you can cover the whole meal in one order.