Chesterhill may be a quiet Morgan County village, but you do not have to go far to find a good pizza. Within a short drive, Athens and nearby small towns offer everything from inventive, wood-fired style pies to classic Ohio thin crust. Whether you are heading out for a casual night in town or grabbing takeout on your way back to the farm or cabin, these spots keep locals and visitors well fed.
Wildly creative toppings and meticulous crust make Avalanche the spot worth planning a pizza run for.
Avalanche leans hard into creative combinations, with pies piled high with quality meats, veggies, and house-made sauces. The crust has that ideal balance of chew and char, so even simple pepperoni feels special. It is an easy choice when you want something a cut above standard delivery pizza.
Big foldable slices and a grab-and-go counter make Goodfella's a natural stop after an evening in Athens.
Goodfella's serves classic New York–style slices that are easy to eat on the move and even easier to share. The menu sticks to the hits—pepperoni, cheese, and a handful of topping combos—so you can be in and out quickly. It is especially handy if you are spending the evening in Athens and want a quick, satisfying bite before the drive back toward Chesterhill.
Crispy thin crust, edge-to-edge toppings, and familiar sides make Donatos an easy crowd-pleaser.
Donatos is a go-to when you are feeding a mix of kids and adults and do not want to overthink the order. The trademark thin crust comes loaded all the way to the edge, so every slice feels substantial. Pair a couple of pizzas with wings and salads, and you are set for a casual night back in Chesterhill or at a nearby rental.
Generous toppings and frequent specials make Plus 1 a smart stop when you need a lot of pizza for not a lot of money.
Plus 1 focuses on hearty, classic pies with plenty of cheese and toppings, along with subs and wings to round out the order. It is the kind of place local teams and big families rely on for post-game meals and gatherings. If your group is based in or around Chesterhill, swinging through The Plains for a large order can be well worth the detour.
For nights when convenience matters more than experimentation, Domino's brings hot pizza and sides out quickly.
Domino's is often the easiest option if you are staying in a rental or farmhouse and want straightforward delivery without the drive into town. The menu covers the basics—customizable pizzas, wings, pasta, and desserts—so everyone at the table can find something. It is especially useful on bad-weather nights when the roads between Chesterhill and Athens feel a bit too long.