01
Best overall pick
B & D Pizza
Downtown Mount Gilead • Small-Town Pizza Parlor • Local Favorite
A classic Mount Gilead mainstay turning out generous, no-nonsense pies that feel made for small-town Friday nights.
If you ask around Chesterville where folks actually go for pizza, B & D is usually the first name that comes up. The crust is sturdy and chewy, toppings are piled on without being fussy, and the whole place has that lived-in, everybody-knows-everybody energy. It’s the kind of shop where a large pepperoni and a pitcher of soda can easily stretch into a whole evening of catching up.
02
Most reliable classic
Pizza Hut
Just Off Oh-95 In Mount Gilead • Family-Friendly Chain Restaurant • Best For Families
Familiar pan pizza, roomy booths, and a relaxed pace make this an easy choice for family dinners after a drive from Chesterville.
When you want something everyone at the table will recognize, the Mount Gilead Pizza Hut is the dependable option close to Chesterville. The thick, buttery pan crust and stuffed crust specialties are the draw, especially for kids and big groups. It’s an easy stop when you’re already in town running errands and need a sit-down meal that doesn’t require much debate.
03
Best thin-crust road-trip stop
Donatos Pizza
Near I-71 In Sunbury • Thin-Crust Pizzeria With Craft Toppings • Worth The Drive
Crisp, edge-to-edge topping coverage on a thin crust makes this Sunbury stop a go-to for folks heading down the interstate from Chesterville.
If you like your pizza cut in squares with toppings all the way to the edge, the Donatos in Sunbury is the play. It’s close enough to the highway that you can swing by on your way to or from Columbus, grab a big order, and be back in Chesterville with everything still hot. The menu leans a bit more modern, with options like loaded chicken pies and pepperoni that crisps up nicely around the edges.
04
Game-day crowd pleaser
Donatos Pizza
South Side Of Mount Vernon • Carryout-Focused Pizza Chain • Best For Big Orders
A Mount Vernon favorite for big, shareable orders when you’re feeding a crowd back in Chesterville.
For parties, game nights, or when extra relatives show up unannounced, the Mount Vernon Donatos is built for volume. Large pies, subs, salads, and wings all travel well, making it easy to pick up a mixed spread and haul it back home. The thin, crispy crust holds up better than most on the drive, so you’re not opening the box to find a soggy mess.
05
Best late-night option
Domino's Pizza
East Side Of Mount Vernon • Fast-Delivery Pizza Chain • Late-Night Pick
Quick-turn pies with lots of customization, ideal when a late craving hits and you want something predictable and hot.
The Mount Vernon Domino’s is the workhorse choice for people who value speed and consistency over atmosphere. Between the build-your-own combinations, specialty pizzas, and cheesy breads, it’s easy to piece together something that satisfies everyone after a long day. It’s especially handy on nights when you’d rather stay home in Chesterville and let someone else handle dinner.