01
Best overall pick
Fire and Stone Pizzeria
Downtown Chillicothe • Wood-Fired Pizzeria And Taproom • Local Date-Night Favorite
Wood-fired pies, creative toppings, and a polished but relaxed downtown vibe make Fire and Stone the go-to for a sit-down pizza night.
This downtown spot leans into a modern, brick-and-wood look, with a menu built around blistered, wood-fired crusts. Expect thoughtful topping combos, rotating specials, and a solid beer list that makes it easy to linger. It’s the place locals suggest when you ask where to sit down for “the good pizza” in Chillicothe.
02
Best for old-school flavor
Jerry's Pizza
Bridge Street Corridor • Classic Hometown Pizza Parlor • Neighborhood Staple
Jerry’s serves the kind of crisp, square-cut pies and hearty subs that feel straight out of a small-town Friday night tradition.
The menu leans classic—think pepperoni-heavy pizzas, baked pasta, and subs—with a focus on reliable, familiar flavors. Regulars swear by the slightly chewy crust and generous cheese, especially on the classic pepperoni and sausage. It’s an easy choice when you want the kind of old-school pizza place every Ohio town seems proud of.
03
Best for families
Giovanni's Pizza
Western Avenue Corridor • Family-Style Italian Buffet And Pizza House • Group-Friendly Favorite
Giovanni’s pairs crowd-pleasing pizzas with pasta, salad, and a buffet-style setup that’s built for families and teams.
Here the draw is volume plus variety: pan and thin crust pizzas share space with pasta, wings, and a full salad bar. Kids and picky eaters do well, because everyone can build a plate their own way. It’s a popular post-game stop and a solid option when you need to feed a mix of ages without overthinking it.
04
Best for delivery night
Cristy's Pizza
Water Street District • Casual Delivery And Carryout Pizza Shop • Go-To Takeout Option
Cristy’s focuses on fast, consistent pies with plenty of toppings, making it a standby for delivery and carryout around town.
This Water Street shop is built around convenience, with a menu full of customizable pizzas, cheesy bread, and wings that travel well. Crust options and specialty combinations keep regulars from getting bored week to week. When locals want something easy that will show up hot at the door, Cristy’s is usually on the shortlist.
05
Best for pizza and a pint
The Dock At Water
Riverside Water Street Strip • Lively Bar And Grill With Scratch-Made Pizzas • Casual Hangout Spot
The Dock at Water is a laid-back bar and grill where hand-tossed pizzas share the stage with wings, burgers, and cold drinks.
Pizza here comes with a full bar and plenty of TVs, making it a natural game-day choice. The crust is heartier than most delivery joints, with toppings piled on to match the bar-food atmosphere. It’s the pick when you want a local place to watch the game, split a few pies, and not rush out afterward.