01
Best lake-day staple
Cassano's Pizza King
Russells Point Near Indian Lake • Classic Dayton-Style Pizzeria And Carryout • Go-To After A Day On The Water
A long-running regional favorite known for its square-cut pies that travel well back to the campsite or cottage.
Cassano's hits the sweet spot for boat-and-beach days: easy parking, fast service, and pizzas that stay crisp even after a short drive around the lake. The thin, edge-to-edge toppings and light sauce are ideal if you’re feeding a crowd that doesn’t all want heavy, doughy slices. Order a couple of deluxe or pepperoni-and-sausage pies and you’ll see why many Indian Lake regulars treat this as part of their weekend routine.
02
Worth-the-drive destination
Six Hundred Downtown
Downtown Bellefontaine • Wood-Fired, Competition-Style Pizzeria • Destination For Serious Pizza Fans
An award-winning Bellefontaine spot turning out blistered, chewy-crust pies in a lively historic-downtown setting.
If you’re willing to drive a bit inland from the lake, Six Hundred Downtown is where you go when you actually want to talk about the pizza afterward. The dough is the star—slow-risen, airy, and baked hot for a leopard-spotted crust that still has some chew. Toppings lean classic Italian with a few creative specials, and the cozy brick-and-wood dining room makes it feel like more of a night out than a quick grab-and-go.
03
Old-school local favorite
Jac & Do's Pizza
East Bellefontaine • Casual Pizza And Pub Spot • Best For Big Groups And Teams
A no-frills Bellefontaine mainstay with generous toppings, roomy tables, and plenty of options beyond pizza.
Jac & Do's is the kind of place locals grew up with—thick layers of cheese, straightforward toppings, pitchers of soda, and plenty of room for teams or extended family. The crust is sturdy enough to handle loaded deluxe or meat pizzas, which makes it a smart choice when everyone wants something different. It’s an easy swing-through on the way back from errands in town, especially if you’re looking to linger over a couple of pies and a basket of wings.
04
Reliable family chain
Pizza Hut
Russells Point Strip • Family-Friendly Chain Pizzeria • Best For Familiar Favorites
A convenient lakeside-area option when you want the classic pan pizza, breadsticks, and salad bar experience everyone recognizes.
For many lake visitors, this Pizza Hut is the default family meetup spot, especially on cooler evenings when outdoor patios lose their appeal. The menu is exactly what you expect—pan and hand-tossed pizzas, stuffed crust, wings, and plenty of kid-pleasing sides—so ordering for picky eaters is painless. Its location on the main drag through Russells Point makes it a quick in-and-out stop on the way back to Chippewa Park.
05
Delivery workhorse
Domino's Pizza
South Bellefontaine • Fast-Delivery Chain Pizza Shop • Late-Night And Delivery Pick
A practical choice for late-night or last-minute pizza runs, with streamlined ordering and quick turnaround.
When you don’t want to leave the cabin or campsite, Domino's is the reliable backup plan that gets hot food to the area quickly. The menu runs from customizable hand-tossed, thin, and pan pizzas to sandwiches and cheesy breads that help stretch a meal for a larger group. It’s not trying to be a destination in itself, but for game nights, storms rolling over the lake, or late arrivals, it’s often the most efficient way to feed everyone.