01
Best overall pick
Phat Daddy's Pizza
London – East High Street • Family-Run Pizzeria And Sports Hangout • Local Favorite For Hearty Pies
Generous, loaded pizzas and a friendly crew make this a go-to stop for Lake Choctaw regulars.
Family-owned and proudly serving the Choctaw Lake area for years, Phat Daddy’s leans into big flavors and big portions. The crust is sturdy enough to handle serious toppings, from classic pepperoni to their heavier specialty combinations. It’s an easy choice when you want reliable carryout after a day on the water or a casual spot to watch a game with a pie on the table.
02
Classic hometown slice
Ronetti's Pizza
Downtown London • Old-School Pizza Parlor • Best For Classic, No-Frills Pizza
A long-running downtown staple serving straightforward, satisfying pizzas in a low-key setting.
Ronetti’s feels like the kind of small-town pizza place many people grew up with: simple menu, familiar faces, and thin, crispy-edged pies. The focus is on tried-and-true toppings and a crust that holds up well for both dine-in and takeout. It’s the spot you choose when you want classic Ohio-style pizza without any fuss.
03
Best for groups and families
Pizza Cottage
Near Madison County Fairgrounds • Regional Pizzeria With A Big Menu • Great For Varied Tastes And Larger Parties
A broad menu of pizzas, pastas, and appetizers makes this an easy crowd-pleaser after lake time.
Pizza Cottage’s London location is a convenient meet-up spot when your group can’t agree on just one style of pizza. The menu runs from build-your-own thin or thicker crust pies to loaded specialty options, plus salads and shareable starters. With plenty of seating and a family-friendly vibe, it’s well suited to team dinners, birthday gatherings, or feeding a hungry crew after a day on the water.
04
Game-day takeout pick
Flyers Pizza & Subs
London – Lafayette Street Corridor • Casual Pizza And Subs Shop • Best For Carryout And Delivery Nights
Crispy-edged pies, solid subs, and efficient service make Flyers a dependable takeout standby.
Flyers is a regional chain with a strong local following, and the London shop is popular for nights when nobody wants to cook. The pizzas tend toward a crisp, slightly thicker crust with well-seasoned sauce and plenty of cheese, and the menu’s subs and wings round out a game-day spread. Order ahead, swing through on your way back from the lake, and you’ll have hot pizza on the table in minutes.
05
East-of-the-lake option
Joseppi's Pizza
West Jefferson • Neighborhood Pizza Joint • Good Stop On The Way To Or From Columbus
A cozy, small-town shop known for its saucy pies and friendly, laid-back service.
If you’re coming to Choctaw Lake from the Columbus side, Joseppi’s in West Jefferson is a convenient place to grab pizza along the way. The crust leans soft and slightly chewy, with a generous layer of sauce that’s a touch sweeter than most. It’s an easy, no-frills stop where the focus is on hot, comforting pies to take home or back to your rental.