01
Best overall pick
Pizza Cottage
South Us-23 Corridor • Family Pizza Restaurant • Crowd-Pleasing All-Rounder
Plenty of toppings, friendly service, and a laid-back dining room make Pizza Cottage a reliable go-to for Circleville pizza night.
Pizza Cottage hits that sweet spot between classic pizza joint and family restaurant, with big portions and a menu that keeps everyone at the table happy. Expect well-loaded pizzas, from straightforward pepperoni to heavier specialty pies, plus salads and subs if someone’s not in a pizza mood. It’s an easy choice when you want somewhere casual, filling, and consistent just outside town.
02
Best for crispy thin crust
Donatos Pizza
Lancaster Pike Strip • Columbus-Style Thin-Crust Pizzeria • Best For Carryout And Delivery
Donatos brings its signature edge-to-edge toppings and cracker-thin crust to Circleville, ideal for fast carryout or delivery.
If you like a light, crunchy crust piled high with toppings, Donatos is the Ohio staple to know. The pizzas are cut in tidy squares, making them easy to share at home or at a small get-together. Order ahead on busy nights; this is a popular stop for locals who want something quick without sacrificing flavor.
03
Best pizza-and-pub combo
Gants Pizza & Pub
Neighborhood Spot North Of Downtown • Pizza Pub With Full Bar • Relaxed Hangout For Friends
Gants pairs hearty pizzas with a true small-town pub feel, making it a comfortable spot to linger over a pie and a drink.
Gants Pizza & Pub feels like the kind of place where the staff quickly learns your name and your order. The pies lean generous and hearty, built to stand up to a cold beer and a long conversation. It’s a solid choice when you want something more social than a quick carryout but still low-key and local.
04
Best downtown tavern pick
Watt Street Tavern
Historic Downtown Circleville • Tavern With Craft Beer And Pizzas • Best For Drinks And A Game
Watt Street Tavern serves satisfying pizzas alongside a strong beer list in a cozy downtown setting.
This is the spot when you want pizza with a side of atmosphere—think exposed brick, TVs for the game, and a mix of regulars and visitors. The pizzas are well-executed bar pies, with enough variety to keep things interesting without overcomplicating the menu. Pair a specialty pie with a locally minded draft and you’ve got an easy downtown evening dialed in.
05
Best grab-and-go option
Zanzis Pizza
East Main Street • Carryout-Focused Pizza Shop • Quick And Budget-Friendly
Zanzis is all about hot, ready-to-go pizzas and value deals that make weeknight dinners painless.
If you’re racing between errands or just don’t feel like cooking, Zanzis is a dependable stop on the east side of town. The focus here is speed and convenience: simple, satisfying pies ready for pickup with minimal waiting. It’s the kind of place locals keep in their back pocket for last-minute gatherings or feeding a hungry crew on a budget.