01
Best overall pick
Domino's Pizza
New Martinsville Riverfront Corridor • Carryout And Delivery Chain Shop • Reliable All-Rounder
Your go-to spot for fast, customizable pizzas just across the river in New Martinsville.
For Clarington residents who want a familiar menu and late-night delivery, Domino’s in New Martinsville is often the most practical choice. The build-your-own options, multiple crust styles, and online deals make it easy to feed a group without overthinking it. It’s a solid all-rounder when you just want hot pizza, quick service, and predictable quality.
02
Classic chain comfort
Pizza Hut
New Martinsville Commercial Strip • Sit-Down Family Pizza Restaurant • Best For Families
A familiar dine-in and takeout spot with pan pizzas, wings, and plenty of space for family dinners.
If you’re driving down from Clarington with kids in tow, the Pizza Hut in New Martinsville is an easy crowd-pleaser. The pan and stuffed-crust pizzas feel like old-school comfort food, and the wider menu of wings and pasta keeps non-pizza eaters happy. It’s a straightforward, no-surprises option for family nights or simple birthday gatherings.
03
Small-town slice stop
Fox's Pizza Den
Near The Square In Woodsfield • Casual Small-Town Pizzeria • Hometown Favorite
A Monroe County staple known for generous toppings and hearty specialty pies.
Fox’s Pizza Den in Woodsfield is a natural choice when you’re already heading to the county seat and want something more local than a big chain. Expect classic American-style pies with a slightly thicker crust and plenty of cheese, plus strombolis and wedges for variety. It’s the kind of place where a large specialty pizza can easily anchor a game-night spread back in Clarington.
04
Dependable Monroe County option
Pizza Hut
Woodsfield Shopping Area • Casual Dine-In And Carryout Spot • Weeknight Standby
A convenient Monroe County Pizza Hut that’s handy for a quick meal before or after errands in town.
For Clarington locals combining a trip to Woodsfield with dinner, this Pizza Hut offers a predictable, easy stop. The buffet-style options (when available) and familiar toppings make it simple to please a mixed group. It’s not fancy, but it’s reliable, with plenty of parking and a straightforward in-and-out experience.
05
Worth-the-drive classic
DeFelice Bros. Pizza
Moundsville Main Corridor • Regional Italian-American Pizzeria • Best For A Special Treat
A regional chain with a loyal following, known for its slightly sweet sauce and edge-to-edge toppings.
DeFelice Bros. in Moundsville is a bit more of a drive from Clarington, but many locals consider it a step up from the big national chains. The pizzas lean toward a classic regional style: balanced sauce, flavorful cheese, and toppings spread generously to the edge. It’s a good call when you want a ‘pizza night out’ that feels a little more like a treat than a default option.