01
Best overall pick
Padrone's Pizza & Pub
Chillicothe – Downtown/Water Street • Lively Local Pizza Pub • Best For Hanging Out After The Game
A hometown pub turning out hearty pies, wings, and cold beer just a quick drive from Clarksburg.
Padrone's feels like the spot where half of Chillicothe ends up after ballgames and local events, and the pizza more than holds its own against the chatter. The crust leans sturdy rather than floppy, built to carry plenty of toppings, and the menu is broad enough to keep non-pizza folks happy too. It is an easy pick when you want a sit-down place with TVs, a buzz of conversation, and hot slices coming out fast.
02
Most reliable chain slice
Donatos Pizza
Chillicothe – North Bridge Street Strip • Thin-Crust Ohio Chain • Best For Big Orders And Carryout
Crisp edge-to-edge thin crust and predictable quality make this Bridge Street Donatos a go-to for quick cravings.
When you are feeding a crowd back in Clarksburg, Donatos on Bridge Street is the kind of place you can call without overthinking it. Their trademark thin crust comes loaded nearly to the rim with toppings, so even a basic pepperoni feels dialed up a notch. Online ordering and efficient pickup make it especially handy on busy weeknights or after long road games.
03
Classic hometown feel
Cardo's Pizza & Pasta
Chillicothe – West End • Old-School Pizza And Pasta Joint • Best For Family Dinners
A cozy, old-school spot where thick, cheesy pies and red-sauce comfort define the meal.
Cardo's has that slightly retro, small-town Ohio feel, with generous cheese, sturdy crust, and plenty of red-sauce comfort dishes on the side. It is the kind of place where families linger over a couple of pizzas, garlic bread, and a big salad bowl in the middle of the table. If you want something that tastes like it has been on the local rotation for years, this is an easy west-side Chillicothe choice.
04
Worth-the-drive Circleville staple
Cristy's Pizza
Circleville – Near Downtown • Casual Central Ohio Pizzeria • Best For Loaded Specialty Pies
Known for its generous toppings and creative specialty combos, Cristy's is a Circleville standby worth the extra miles.
Cristy's leans into the classic Central Ohio style: plenty of toppings, lots of cheese, and a crust that stays just crisp enough under the weight. The specialty pizzas are the move here, from meat-heavy builds to veggie-loaded options that still feel indulgent. Pair it with a quick stroll through downtown Circleville and you have an easy weekend outing from Clarksburg.
05
Small-town favorite
Giovanni's Pizza
Washington Court House – Just Off The Courthouse Square • Laid-Back Local Pizza Shop • Best For Classic Small-Town Vibe
A relaxed, no-rush pizza spot where locals linger over classic pies, subs, and salads.
Giovanni's in Washington Court House feels every bit the small-town institution, from the friendly counter crew to the steady stream of regulars picking up their usual. The pizzas are straightforward and satisfying, with that familiar slightly chewy crust and a sauce leaning a bit sweet, as many Ohioans prefer. It is an easy, low-stress stop when you want to combine a pizza run with other errands in town.