01
Best overall pick
Bella Sorella Pizza
Clayton • Wood-Fired Mobile Pizzeria • Best Overall Pick
Family-run wood-fired pizza that feels tailor-made for Clayton's neighborhood vibe.
Bella Sorella brings a serious wood-fired oven and a tight, well-edited menu to Clayton, with blistered crusts and toppings that skew more artisanal than chain. Expect thoughtfully balanced pies with good char, generous fresh basil, and seasonal specials that reward repeat visits. It is the spot locals recommend first when you say you want great pizza without leaving town.
02
Classic Dayton-style experience
Marion's Piazza - Englewood
Englewood On National Road • Classic Dayton-Style Thin-Crust Parlor • Go-To For Nostalgic Locals
A big, throwback dining room serving cracker-thin pizza that defines the Dayton style for many locals.
The Englewood Marion's Piazza is a short hop from Clayton and a rite of passage for anyone exploring Dayton-area pizza. The ultra-thin, square-cut pies come loaded edge-to-edge with finely chopped toppings, perfect for sharing with a group. The large, no-rush dining room makes it an easy choice for birthday parties, team dinners, or a casual night out with a crowd.
03
Best for big takeout orders
Cassano's Pizza King - Englewood
Englewood Near The Interstate • Carryout-Focused Neighborhood Pizza Shop • Top Choice For Feeding A Crowd
A long-running Dayton brand turning out saucy, square-cut pies that travel well back to Clayton.
The Englewood Cassano's is a practical favorite when you need several pizzas fast for a family gathering or game night. Their signature crust is slightly thicker than some Dayton-style competitors, with plenty of sauce and a salty, nostalgic cheese blend. Order a mix of classics and their generously topped deluxe pies, and you can easily cover a range of tastes without breaking the budget.
04
Best beer-and-pizza hangout
Old Scratch Pizza
Downtown Dayton Near The River • Bustling Craft Beer Hall With Wood-Fired Pies • Ideal For Beer Lovers And Groups
Lively counter-service spot pairing charred, Neapolitan-inspired pies with one of Dayton's best craft beer lists.
Old Scratch is worth the short drive from Clayton if you want a night out that feels more like a city destination than a quick slice. Pizzas come with puffy, leopard-spotted crusts and toppings that range from classic margherita to spicy, chef-y combinations with hot honey or house-made sausage. Long communal tables, a busy bar, and fast-moving service make it easy to roll in with friends or visiting family and hang out over a couple of pies and pints.
05
Most creative pies
Wheat Penny Oven and Bar
Dayton Just West Of The Oregon District • Seasonal Italian Spot With Creative Pizzas • Great For Leisurely Nights Out
Inventive, chef-driven pizzas with a slightly chewy crust and toppings you will not find at a typical strip-mall shop.
Wheat Penny leans into the restaurant side of pizza, with a menu that feels just as comfortable for a date night as it does for a relaxed dinner with friends. The crust has a satisfying chew and blister, and toppings often showcase market vegetables, house-made sausage, and bright, herb-forward sauces. It is the place to go when you want to linger over a cocktail, split a couple of pizzas, and see a more culinary take on the Dayton pizza scene.