01
Best overall pick
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill
Ottawa • Lively Family Pizza And Grill • Local Favorite
Big, shareable pies, a full menu, and a bustling dining room make Beer Barrel worth the drive from Cloverdale.
In nearby Ottawa, Beer Barrel delivers the classic Northwest Ohio pizza-and-grill experience: thick, cheesy pies, generous toppings, and plenty of booths for groups. The menu runs well beyond pizza with wings, sandwiches, and hearty appetizers, so it is easy to keep everyone at the table happy. It is a strong choice when you want to sit down, linger over a meal, and make the most of a night out of town.
02
Best for big appetites
Fat Jack's Pizza
Lima - Elida Road Corridor • Casual Carryout Pizza Joint • Best For Takeout Feasts
Known for hefty pies and value-oriented specials, Fat Jack's is ideal when you are feeding a hungry crew back in Cloverdale.
Fat Jack's in Lima leans into generous portions and crowd-pleasing toppings, from classic pepperoni to loaded deluxe combinations. The crust runs on the heartier side, holding up well on the drive back up from Lima. Call ahead on game nights or weekends and you can be in and out quickly with enough pizza to cover a family gathering or a late shift at the farm.
03
Most reliable weeknight option
Marco's Pizza
Delphos • Neighborhood Chain Pizzeria • Go-To For Customizable Pies
Marco's in Delphos offers consistent, build-your-own pizzas and familiar sides that travel well back to Cloverdale.
If you like to fine-tune your order, Marco's is a safe bet, with multiple crust styles, sauces, and topping combinations. It is an easy detour when you are already passing through Delphos, and the streamlined pickup setup makes quick work of weeknight dinners. Add cheezy bread or wings and you have a complete spread without much planning.
04
Best for thin-crust fans
Donatos Pizza
Lima - East Side • Crispy Thin-Crust Chain • Edge-To-Edge Topping Specialist
Donatos is the pick if you crave ultra-thin crust with toppings spread edge-to-edge on every slice.
On Lima’s east side, Donatos serves its signature thin crust that bakes up crisp but still sturdy enough for the drive north. The edge-to-edge topping style means every bite is loaded, which works well if you are sharing a couple of larges among friends or coworkers. It is especially good for those who prefer a lighter, crunchier base over thicker, doughy styles.
05
Best for families
Pizza Hut
Ottawa - East Main Corridor • Classic Dine-In Chain Pizzeria • Comfortingly Familiar Choice
Ottawa’s Pizza Hut offers the nostalgic pan-pizza experience, with space to sit down and linger over a meal.
When you want something familiar and kid-friendly, the Ottawa Pizza Hut hits the mark with its pan and hand-tossed pizzas, breadsticks, and simple pasta dishes. It is an easy stop if you are already in town running errands, and the dining room setup makes it convenient for groups who want to eat right away rather than haul everything back to Cloverdale. For many locals, it is the default “everyone can agree on this” option.