01
Best overall pick
R Pizza Place
Historic Main Street • Scratch-Made Hometown Pizzeria • Local Favorite
Columbiana's go-to spot for generous, from-scratch pies in a relaxed, no-fuss dining room.
This long-running Main Street staple is beloved for its hand-tossed crust, house-made sauce, and classic toppings piled on heavy. Expect big, shareable pizzas, wings, and straightforward salads that work just as well for a family dinner as they do for a post-game team outing. Call ahead on weekend nights; it fills up fast and the phones stay busy.
02
Best for big groups
Fox's Pizza Den
North Main Street • Family-Friendly Chain Pizzeria • Best For Sharing
Known for its oversized party pies, Fox's is where locals turn when they need to feed a crowd on a budget.
Fox's Pizza Den leans into volume, with massive square-cut pizzas and party-sized options that make sense for birthday gatherings, team parties, or casual office lunches. The menu stretches beyond pizza into strombolis, wedges, and salads, so everyone can find something. It's a practical choice when you want easy ordering and plenty of food without overthinking it.
03
Best sit-down Italian
Belleria Pizza & Italian Restaurant
South Avenue / Firestone Farms Area • Italian Family Restaurant And Pizzeria • Sit-Down Italian Pick
A local outpost of a regional favorite, pairing hearty pies with red-sauce Italian comfort dishes.
Belleria is the spot when you want pizza but also crave a full Italian dinner with the family. Thick, cheesy pies share the menu with baked pastas, sandwiches, and old-school appetizers, so it's easy to turn a quick bite into a lingering meal. The vibe is casual and welcoming, making it a solid choice for date nights that still feel low-key or multi-generation gatherings.
04
Classic chain comfort
Pizza Hut
West State Route 14 • National Pizza Chain Restaurant • Best For Familiar Favorites
A reliable stop for pan pizza, breadsticks, and wings when you want the exact flavors you grew up with.
Just off State Route 14, the local Pizza Hut delivers the brand's trademark pan and stuffed-crust pies alongside pasta, wings, and indulgent sides. It's a natural fit for family dinners when everyone already has a favorite order, and for road-trippers looking for something predictable right off the highway. Online deals and combo packs make it easy to feed a group without surprises.
05
Game-night go-to
Pizza Joe's
East Oh-14 • Casual Slice-And-Wings Shop • Takeout And Delivery Pick
A regional chain known for its soft crust, crowd-pleasing toppings, and game-day friendly combos.
Pizza Joe's leans fast and flexible, with pizzas, subs, and wings built for carryout or delivery. The crust skews softer and slightly thicker, which makes the slices sturdy enough for extra cheese and loaded toppings. It's the spot locals call for Friday nights at home, casual watch parties, or quick dinners when cooking is off the table.