01
Best overall pick
Fat Jack's Pizza
Columbus Grove Village Center • Small-Town Carryout Pizzeria • Local Favorite
Columbus Grove’s own Fat Jack’s is the classic small-town pizza stop for generous, cheesy pies and fast carryout.
This is the place locals rattle off first when someone mentions grabbing pizza in town. The crust leans hearty and comforting, with plenty of cheese and toppings that feel built for sharing with a crowd. Call ahead on busy nights; pickup can get lively when there’s a big game or school event.
02
Short drive for classic pies
Pisanello's Pizza
Downtown Ottawa • Classic Midwest Pizzeria • Best For Families
Pisanello’s in nearby Ottawa serves familiar, crowd-pleasing pizzas in a relaxed small-town setting.
A quick drive from Columbus Grove, Pisanello’s feels like the kind of spot that has seen plenty of team parties and family birthdays. The menu leans into classic combinations, thick-with-toppings specialty pies, and the kind of garlic bread and salads that round out an easy dinner. It’s a comfortable choice when you want to sit down, linger, and let everyone pick their own favorite slice style.
03
Chain comfort pick
Marco's Pizza
East Side Of Ottawa • Carryout And Delivery Chain • Game-Night Go-To
Marco’s in Ottawa delivers consistent, customizable pizzas that are ideal for busy nights and big orders.
When you want something predictable and fast, Marco’s is usually the easiest play from Columbus Grove. The crust options, flavored crusts, and mix-and-match toppings make it simple to keep both picky eaters and adventurous toppings fans happy. Pair a couple of large pizzas with cheesy bread and wings, and you’ve got a full spread ready for game night or a last-minute get-together.
04
Worth-the-drive classic
Jac & Do's Pizza
North Side Of Lima • Old-School Regional Pizza Joint • Road-Trip Pick
Jac & Do’s in Lima is a long-running regional favorite known for its nostalgic, no-frills pizza.
If you don’t mind a bit more driving, Jac & Do’s is the kind of old-school spot many northwest Ohio families grew up on. Expect a straightforward menu, crispy-edged pizzas, and plenty of cheese, served in a setting that feels unchanged in the best way. It’s a fun option when you want pizza to be the excuse for a simple evening out of town.
05
Big-group standby
Pizza Hut
South Side Of Ottawa • National Pizza Chain Restaurant • Best For Big Groups
Ottawa’s Pizza Hut offers familiar pan and stuffed-crust pies with plenty of space for teams and large families.
Sometimes you just want the comfort of a pizza you already know, and Pizza Hut covers that base for many Columbus Grove families. The classic pan crust, buffet-style options at certain times, and roomy seating make it convenient for youth teams, birthday groups, or casual gatherings. It’s not fancy, but it’s easy to organize, easy to find, and rarely a hard sell for kids.