01
Best overall pick
Nana & Pap's Pizzeria & Ice Cream
Downtown Commercial Point • Small-Town Pizzeria And Ice-Cream Shop • Best Overall Pick
A hometown favorite for generous pies, friendly service, and a nostalgic small-town feel right on Scioto Street.
Nana & Pap's is the kind of place where the staff remembers your usual order and kids sprint for the ice-cream case while the pizza bakes. The crust leans classic and sturdy, with plenty of cheese and toppings that feel more like a family kitchen than a chain. It’s an easy choice for a relaxed dinner after practice or a low-key Friday night in town.
02
Classic hometown slice
Mo's Pizza
Scioto Street, Commercial Point • No-Frills Carryout Pizzeria • Best For Quick Carryout
Straightforward, well-priced pies that locals rely on for fast, no-drama carryout.
Mo's Pizza focuses on the essentials: hot pies, fair prices, and quick turnaround on busy weeknights. Expect classic toppings, hearty portions, and a crust that holds up well on the drive home. It’s the go-to when you want to swing through Commercial Point, grab dinner, and be back at the table in minutes.
03
Game-day go-to
Dough Boyz Pizza
Front Street, Commercial Point • Casual Pizza And Wings Joint • Best For Feeding A Crowd
A reliable stop for big pizzas, wings, and shareable sides when you’re feeding a hungry crew.
Dough Boyz leans into the game-day vibe, with pizzas built for sharing and plenty of sides to round out an order. The crust has a satisfying chew, and toppings are layered on with a heavier hand than most chains. Call ahead for larger orders and it becomes an easy anchor for parties, family gatherings, or Sunday football.
04
Short-drive favorite
Flyers Pizza & Subs (Grove City)
Grove City Town Center • Family Pizza And Subs Shop • Best For Families
A short hop from Commercial Point, Flyers offers thin, square-cut pies, subs, and a lively, kid-friendly dining room.
Many Commercial Point residents head up to Flyers when they want a sit-down spot with more room and a bigger menu. The classic Columbus-style, square-cut pizza works well for sharing, and the subs and salads make it easy to keep everyone at the table happy. It’s a practical pick for family dinners, youth teams, or meeting friends halfway from Columbus.
05
Columbus-style classic
Massey's Pizza (Grove City)
Buckeye Parkway, Grove City • Old-School Thin-Crust Pizzeria • Best For Columbus-Style Thin Crust
Known for crisp, square-cut pies piled with toppings, Massey's is worth the quick drive for true Columbus-style pizza fans.
Massey's brings a more old-school feel, with a ultra-thin crust that bakes up crisp and carries plenty of cheese and pepperoni to the edge. It’s a smart choice when you want something a little different from the heavier, hand-tossed styles closer to town. Pair a large pie with a salad or garlic bread and you’ve got an easy, shareable meal before heading back toward Commercial Point.