01
Best overall pick
Crowtown Pizza
Downtown Coshocton • Small-Town Pizzeria With Hearty Pies • Local Favorite
A cozy downtown shop turning out generously topped pies that feel custom-made for small-town pizza night.
Crowtown Pizza is the kind of place people in and around Conesville talk about when they say they "know a really good local pizza joint." The crust lands in that sweet spot between chewy and crisp, with plenty of cheese and toppings that are layered on with a hometown sense of generosity. It is an easy choice when you want something better than chain pizza without driving far from the river.
02
For classic pies and subs
Pizza Point
Near Coshocton Courthouse Square • Hand-Tossed Pies And Italian-American Comfort Food • Best For Classic Slices
A laid-back spot known for straightforward, well-made pizzas and no-frills comfort food.
Pizza Point keeps things simple in the best way, focusing on well-browned cheese, balanced sauce, and a crust sturdy enough to fold. Beyond pizza, locals like it for subs, wings, and those nights when everyone wants something a little different but still wants to order from one place. It is a reliable stop if you are coming into Coshocton for errands and want to grab a box on the way back to Conesville.
03
Delivery go-to
Plus 1 Pizza
Walnut Street Corridor In Coshocton • Carryout And Delivery Pizza Shop • Delivery Standout
A hometown chain known for crowd-pleasing specialty pizzas and dependable delivery out of Coshocton.
Plus 1 Pizza is the place many Coshocton County families default to when they want familiar flavors and easy ordering. The menu leans into specialty combinations, cheesy bread, and wings, making it simple to feed a mixed group without overthinking it. If you value quick pickup or delivery and like the comfort of a local mini-chain, this one belongs in your rotation.
04
Fast and predictable
Domino's Pizza
South End Of Coshocton • National Delivery Chain • Late-Night Pick
A familiar option when you want fast delivery, build-your-own pies, and app-based deals.
Domino's in Coshocton covers the essentials: quick turnaround, lots of crust options, and plenty of coupons if you like to stack deals. It is not trying to be gourmet, but the ability to track your order and customize everything from sauce to toppings makes it a practical go-to. For late-night study sessions, game days, or last-minute plans, this is the spot that reliably answers the phone.
05
Best for groups
Pizza Hut
Eastern Coshocton Shopping Strip • Sit-Down Chain With Pan And Stuffed-Crust Pies • Family-Friendly Choice
A classic dine-in and carryout choice with familiar pan pizza, wings, and shareable sides.
Coshocton’s Pizza Hut is tailor-made for teams, birthday gatherings, and family nights when everyone wants something recognizable. Thick, buttery pan crust and stuffed-crust options anchor the menu, with wings, pasta, and salad to round out the table. If you are heading in from Conesville with a crowd, it is an easy spot where nobody has to study the menu too hard.